Ex-Hedley singer Jacob Hoggard concludes his testimony in sexual assault trial
-- WARNING -- The following details of the sexual assault case may be disturbing, discretion is advised.
Jacob Hoggard wrapped up his testimony in his sexual assault trial Wednesday morning after the Crown cross-examined him on apparent gaps in his memory.
From left, Jacob Hoggard, Crown attorney Lilly Gates and defence lawyer Megan Savard are seen in a court illustration in Haileybury, Ont., on, Oct. 1, 2024. (Photo by Alexandra Newbould /THE CANADIAN PRESS)
Hoggard has pleaded not guilty and denied raping, choking and hitting his accuser after his band Hedley performed at a concert eight years ago.
The ex-lead singer of the band told a jury this week that he and the complainant had a consensual one-night stand after flirting and kissing during a bonfire after-party following the show in Kirkland Lake, Ont.
During cross-examination late Tuesday and early Wednesday, prosecutor Peter Keen tried to poke holes in Hoggard's description of the night.
He established that Hoggard doesn't have a clear memory of the beginning of the sexual activity in his hotel room, whether there could have been attempted anal sex, as the complainant alleged, and whether Hoggard may have asked to urinate on the woman.
In the woman's earlier testimony, she described feeling disgusted when, she said, Hoggard joined her in the shower following the alleged rape and asked if he could urinate on her. She said she told him no, but he did it anyway.
Hoggard has said the opposite happened. He said Tuesday that after the two engaged in oral sex in the bathtub, he asked her to urinate on him and she did so.
Keen tried to suggest to Hoggard that the urination would have been "much more in keeping with a coercive sexual encounter," but defence lawyer Megan Savard objected.
'Highly problematic'
"To suggest that certain types of sexual acts are inherently less consensual I think is highly problematic," she said.
The prosecutor tried to rephrase the question but Savard rose for a second time.
"I'm going to object again, perhaps on behalf of every person in society who has any kind of fringe sexual practice," she said. "I think this is an offensive line of questioning."
Keen concluded his questions not long after that.
In her re-examination, Savard got several answers from Hoggard about his usual practices during sex. She asked whether he had any memory of actually urinating on the complainant.
"I would remember her letting me do that," he said.
She also revisited the question of anal sex, and whether Hoggard would have attempted it prior to vaginal intercourse as the complainant said took place.
"I never do that first," he said.
Lighting operator testified
After Hoggard's testimony, the lighting operator for the Hedley concert, Jeremy Van Delft, was called as a witness.
While Hoggard had told court he went straight from the concert to the hotel to build the bonfire, Van Delft said the band and crew, including Hoggard, went to a bar after the show before returning to the hotel.
At the bonfire, he said he saw Hoggard and a woman speaking, and at the end of the night he saw the two of them walking back toward the hotel together.
Van Delft said he saw them enter Hoggard's hotel room via an interior hallway, and at least two other members of the crew or band were in the hallway at the same time.
The complainant had given a similar description of their entry into the room, while Hoggard had said he remembered entering through the room's patio doors.
Savard's co-counsel Kally Ho also asked Van Delft about common practice when it came to transporting the band back and forth, a job someone known as the "runner" would do.
- Download the CTV News app now
- Get local breaking news alerts
- Daily newsletter with the top local stories emailed to your inbox
The complainant had described entering a van outside the venue, along with members of the band and some teenage girls, in order to get to the bonfire after-party. She said she remembered a minivan with a sliding door.
Van Delft said it would have been "unlikely" and "unprofessional of the runner" to allow an unescorted fan inside the same vehicle as the band.
Eric Clarke, who said he lives in Kirkland Lake and worked as one of two runners that day, testified next. He agreed that when a band is being transported, the vehicle is their "personal space" and guests would not be invited in.
Hoggard, Van Delft and Clarke all described the vehicle being used for transportation that day as a white, 15-seat van that did not have a sliding door.
Clarke said some time after the concert, the other runner gave him and two teenage girls a ride to the hotel, where the bonfire was underway.
'I may have been a little bit rude'
Once they got on the road, he said, "I may have been a little bit rude" in asking them which one would be having sex with Hoggard.
Clarke said that after reading a news article about Hoggard's trial, he assumed the complainant was one of the two girls he rode in the van with. But when shown a photo of the complainant taken that night, he said he couldn't confirm if she was one of them. He also agreed the runner would have made other trips between the venue and the hotel.
Last Friday, the complainant had been shown a photo of Clarke and the other runner during her cross-examination. She said she did not recognize them, but ultimately agreed it was possible they were in the van.
The defence is expected to conclude its case on Thursday, with closing arguments from both sides to follow.
Justice Robin Tremblay, left to right, Assistant Crown Attorney Peter Keen, Crown Attorney Lilly Gates, Hoggard's lawyers Kally Ho, Megan Savard and Hoggard are shown in a courtroom sketch in Haileybury, Ont., Sept. 23, 2024. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Alexandra Newbould
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Oct. 2, 2024.
Background
Jacob Hoggard was charged in 2022 for an alleged sexual assault in Kirkland Lake on June 25, 2016.
His former band had performed the night before at the small town's homecoming festival.
In December 2022, he elected to be tried by a jury rather than by a judge alone.
Fourteen jurors were selected Sept. 23, including two alternates. The two alternates were dismissed as the testimony got underway Sept. 24.
Tremblay is presiding over the trial at the Haileybury courthouse.
The case is being prosecuted by Crown Attorney Lilly Gates and Assistant Crown Attorney Peter Keen while Hoggard is being defended by attorneys Megan Savard and Kally Ho.
Ontario Provincial Police Sgt. Dalton Crockett, the lead investigator in the case, is sitting behind the Crown attorney's table and expects to be present throughout the trial.
Hoggard stood up in court Sept. 23 and pled not guilty to the sexual assault charges.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Bloc won't hold Liberals 'hostage' over seniors' benefits: cabinet minister
Liberal cabinet minister Steven Guilbeault says the Liberals will not be 'held hostage' by the Bloc Quebecois' demand to expand Old Age Security to more seniors.
Police identify Toronto victim of alleged serial killer
Toronto police have identified the woman who was allegedly killed by a suspected serial killer earlier this month.
Missing father, kids spotted in New Zealand wilderness 3 years after disappearance: police
A New Zealand man who disappeared with his three children in 2021 was spotted on a farm along the country's northwest coast, police say.
No jail time for man who fatally stabbed senior in Vancouver
A man who stabbed a senior to death in Vancouver's Biltmore Hotel building in 2020 has been given a conditional sentence for the killing, meaning he will not serve any jail time if he remains on good behaviour in the community.
Job growth numbers 'good news' in Canada but there are concerns, according to an economist
An economist says the latest job growth numbers in Canada are 'good news,' but he has concerns following Statistic Canada's report.
EXCLUSIVE: 'We were privileged to be friends with our sister': Family mourns murdered N.S. woman
More than a month after the murder of Nova Scotia woman Esther Jones, her family continues to grapple with the loss.
Hot-air balloon strikes and collapses radio tower in Albuquerque during festival
A hot-air balloon struck and collapsed a radio tower Friday in Albuquerque, New Mexico, during the city's famous festival -- the second time in 20 years that a balloon has come into contact with the tower.
B.C. billionaire posts third large sign criticizing NDP ahead of the election
British Columbia billionaire Chip Wilson has put up yet another billboard message to voters, his third post outside his multimillion-dollar mansion in NDP Leader David Eby's own riding.
Longueuil woman charged after 10-year-old boy scalded with boiling water
A woman from Montreal's South Shore appeared in court on Friday on charges of aggravated assault after allegedly scalding a 10-year-old boy with boiling water more than one week ago.