Complainant breaks down as cross-examination resumes in Hoggard sexual assault trial
-- WARNING -- The following details of the sexual assault case may be disturbing, discretion is advised.
The emotional cross-examination of the woman accusing Jacob Hoggard of sexual assault continued at his trial Friday, as the Canadian musician's defence lawyer sought to highlight possible issues with the complainant's memory.
The woman, whose identity is protected by a publication ban, alleges Hoggard raped, choked, slapped and urinated on her in his hotel room after she attended his band's concert and a bonfire after-party in Kirkland Lake, Ont., eight years ago.
Her testimony at the court in Haileybury, a community in northeastern Ontario, has spanned most of the week.
Hoggard, the lead singer of the band Hedley, pleaded not guilty to a charge of sexual assault when the trial began on Monday.
The defence and Crown agree that a sexual encounter between Hoggard and his accuser took place. Prosecutors are seeking to prove that the complainant gave no consent.
- Download the CTV News app now
- Get local breaking news alerts
- Daily newsletter with the top local stories emailed to your inbox
The woman broke down in sobs and requested a break about 20 minutes into the day while under intense questioning from defence lawyer Megan Savard on Friday about her memories of the alleged assault.
The woman had testified earlier this week that Hoggard took out a guitar when they entered his hotel room and that she expected him to play music, but that he put it down immediately and started removing her clothing despite her protests that she felt uncomfortable.
Savard suggested that what actually happened was that Hoggard played some songs for her, which the woman denied.
"You're skipping over that fact for the jury because you think that hurts your case," Savard said.
"No," said the woman.
"It sounds pretty romantic," the defence lawyer said.
"No," repeated the complainant.
"And you don't want to admit to the jury that you were in a romantic situation with this --"
"No," the woman interrupted forcefully.
"-- with this man when you had a boyfriend," Savard continued.
"I thought of my boyfriend," the complainant said, beginning to cry. "But nothing of it was romantic or anything that I wanted. I didn't ask for this to happen to me."
Savard went on to ask for specifics about how the complainant's clothes were removed. The complainant had previously said she didn't remember how exactly it happened.
On Friday morning, she suggested her skirt had been pulled down, but under questioning from Savard the woman later said that method of removal was just a "guess," and that her memories of that part of the night are "blurry."
"I'm suggesting to you that the clothes that you have no memory of him taking off were clothes that you assisted in removing," Savard said.
The complainant denied the suggestion.
As Savard continued to push on whether the woman's testimony was based on emotions rather than recall, the complainant collapsed into tears and requested some time away from the courtroom.
When court resumed about 15 minutes later, Savard took the complainant to an earlier part of the evening and the woman eventually said some of her answers were based on assumptions rather than concrete memories.
Savard showed the accuser and the jury a photograph of two men and identified one of them as the person who had let the complainant into the backstage area of the concert where a van was waiting to take Hedley fans to that night's after-party.
At first, the complainant denied he could have been the person who let her in, saying she didn't recognize his face. After a belaboured exchange during which the complainant did not always seem to follow the line of questioning, she ultimately conceded that it was possible.
"And it just took about two minutes to get you to give that answer, because you understand how serious it is to give a wrong answer under oath, right?" Savard said.
"I don't want to lie," the complainant said.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Sept. 27, 2024.
Background
Hoggard was charged in 2022 with sexual assault in relation to an incident that allegedly occurred in Kirkland Lake, Ont., on June 25, 2016.
He performed with his band Hedley at the Kirkland Lake Homecoming festival the day before the alleged incident.
Superior Court Justice Robin Tremblay is presiding over the trial at the Haileybury courthouse in Temiskaming Shores.
The trial is expected to last seven days, but two weeks have been set aside.
Hoggard is being defended by attorneys Megan Savard and Kally Ho.
Throughout the proceedings, the accused can be seen sitting at a table next to his legal team wearing a black suit, white dress shirt and black tie.
He pleaded not guilty to the charge against him Monday.
The case is being prosecuted by Assistant Crown Attorney Peter Keen and Crown Attorney Lilly Gates.
Hoggard was the lead singer of the rock band Hedley until 2018 when the band announced it went into an indefinite hiatus.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING Rescuers race to free people trapped by Hurricane Helene after storm kills at least 21 in 4 states
Emergency crews rushed Friday to rescue people trapped in flooded homes after Helene roared ashore as a powerful Category 4 hurricane in Florida, generating a massive storm surge and knocking out power to millions of customers in several states. At least 21 people were reported dead in four states.
Family of man killed by Calgary police issues statement
The family of Jon Wells, a man killed by Calgary police earlier this month, say they are seeking time to grieve their loss.
CSIS says a former parliamentarian may have worked on behalf of a foreign government
A former parliamentarian is suspected of 'having worked to influence parliamentary business' on behalf of an unnamed foreign government, Canada's spy service told a federal inquiry Friday.
1 person hospitalized, 550 people symptomatic after illness outbreak at P.E.I. shellfish festival
More than 550 symptomatic people responded to an online questionnaire about a gastrointestinal illness at a Prince Edward Island shellfish festival last weekend.
Maggie Smith, scene-stealing actor famed for Harry Potter and 'Downton Abbey,' dies at 89
Maggie Smith, the masterful, scene-stealing actor who won an Oscar for 1969 film 'The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie' and gained new fans in the 21st century as the dowager Countess of Grantham in 'Downton Abbey' and Professor Minerva McGonagall in the Harry Potter films, died Friday. She was 89.
Israel says it struck Hezbollah's headquarters as huge explosions rocked Beirut
A series of intense Israeli airstrikes hit one of Beirut's heavily populated southern suburbs on Friday as blasts were heard throughout the Lebanese capital.
What's 'chroming'? Experts explain the dangerous social media trend among youths
Chroming, or getting high via inhaling hydrocarbons by misusing a variety of legal products, is trending among adolescents, and it sometimes ends in death.
Police make four more arrests in viral video that showed woman stealing Porsche from Mississauga driveway
Police have arrested four more people in connection with a viral video that showed a woman stealing a Porsche from a Mississauga driveway and then striking its owner as she attempted to flee the scene.
Iranian operatives charged in the U.S. with hacking Donald Trump's presidential campaign
The U.S. Justice Department unsealed criminal charges Friday against three Iranian operatives suspected of hacking Donald Trump's presidential campaign and disseminating stolen information to media organizations.