Sudbury jury reaches verdict in murder trial
Warning: This story includes graphic descriptions of a murder scene many will find upsetting. Reader caution strongly is advised.
A verdict has been reached on Day 2 of jury deliberations Wednesday afternoon at the Sudbury courthouse in the second-degree murder trial of Felicity Altiman.
The body of Robert Keskinen was found in his Kathleen Street apartment on Boxing Day 2020. He had been stabbed to death. (Obituary photo)
After three weeks of testimony, the jury -- consisting of six men and six women – began deliberations around noon Tuesday on whether Altiman killed Robert Keskinen, 75, in December 2020.
Word that a verdict has been reached came around 1 p.m. Wednesday, after the jury was sequestered overnight.
As of 1:33 p.m., the two Crown attornies, defence attorney and defendant sit at the tables in front of the judge's bench awaiting Justice Dan Cornell's return.
Altiman is wearing a black, long-sleeved casual shirt with white stripes down both arms and her brown hair up in a bun.
- Download the CTV News app now
- Get local breaking news alerts
- Daily newsletter with the top local stories emailed to your inbox
Altiman, 43, has been in jail since her arrest Jan. 7, 2021.
Cornell called the Crown and defence back to the courtroom around 10 a.m. Wednesday after receiving a note containing three questions from the jury:
- What does state of mind mean?
- What constitutes reasonable doubt? For example, does 80 per cent mean reasonable doubt?
- How far off can theories be made from the facts?
Cornell read the questions aloud in the order in which they were written and the three parties discussed the wording the judge would use to answer them without the jury present.
Cornell pointed out that the jury was first asked to determine whether the Crown proved its case beyond a reasonable doubt.
If they are considering the state of mind, he said, they should have already made a decision about reasonable doubt.
Defence attorney Steven Hinkson argued that the judge should just answer the questions that the jury asked and not go into detail or tell them how to address the questions.
Cornell told the jury when they returned to the courtroom around 11:30 a.m. that they must first decide if Altiman killed Keskinen.
Hinkson also disagreed with the judge and Crown on giving the jury two pieces of evidence as examples but was ultimately overruled.
"Two pieces of evidence that may be of particular importance: If Ms. Altiman stabbed him more than 100 times, can there be any doubt about what she intended," Cornell said.
"The other piece of evidence on this point that struck me of particular importance was the after-the-fact conduct when she told her brother that ‘something bad has happened and I may be in trouble.'"
The answer to the state of mind question included the understanding of intent.
"Either she intended to cause his death or cause bodily harm that would cause his death or that death was likely to result and would have been reckless if death would occur or not," Cornell said.
"(If) you found Ms. Altiman stabbed him, the evidence shows he was stabbed more than 100 times and cut off his scrotum, what conclusion can you draw from that?"
All parties agreed that the judge can’t offer a percentage in relation to reasonable doubt, citing case law that proof is more than the balance of probabilities but doesn’t have to be absolute certainty.
"It can’t be imaginary, far-fetched or frivolous. It must be reasonable," Cornell explained to the jury.
"Not based on sympathy or prejudice, based on reason and common sense. More than that, it is a doubt that logically arises from the evidence or lack of evidence. The probable or likely guilt is not enough."
He explained that the Crown does not have to prove anything with absolute certainty, as that is nearly impossible.
In response to the jury’s last question about how far off theories can be made, he said "The simple answer is they cannot."
"Theories are not facts," Cornell said.
"You must rely on the evidence that came forward. This is largely a circumstantial case so you will have to draw inferences."
CTVNewsNorthernOntario.ca will continue to monitor the case and bring updates as soon as they are available.
Background
Robert Keskinen, 75, was found dead in his Kathleen Street apartment on Boxing Day 2020 during a wellness check.
He had more than 100 stab wounds and his scrotum cut off and stuffed in his mouth.
Felicity Altiman was charged with his murder on Jan. 7, 2021 and has remained in custody since.
The three-week trial started Oct. 1.
Defence attorney Steven Hinkson called no witnesses in the case.
Hinkson offered an alternate theory that Altiman stole from the man after she found him dead, but isn’t responsible for his murder.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Richard Perry, record producer behind 'You're So Vain' and other hits, dies at 82
Richard Perry, a hitmaking record producer with a flair for both standards and contemporary sounds whose many successes included Carly Simon’s 'You’re So Vain,' Rod Stewart’s 'The Great American Songbook' series and a Ringo Starr album featuring all four Beatles, died Tuesday. He was 82.
Hong Kong police issue arrest warrants and bounties for six activists including two Canadians
Hong Kong police on Tuesday announced a fresh round of arrest warrants for six activists based overseas, with bounties set at $1 million Hong Kong dollars for information leading to their arrests.
Read Trudeau's Christmas message
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau issued his Christmas message on Tuesday. Here is his message in full.
Stunning photos show lava erupting from Hawaii's Kilauea volcano
One of the world's most active volcanoes spewed lava into the air for a second straight day on Tuesday.
Indigenous family faced discrimination in North Bay, Ont., when they were kicked off transit bus
Ontario's Human Rights Tribunal has awarded members of an Indigenous family in North Bay $15,000 each after it ruled they were victims of discrimination.
What is flagpoling? A new ban on the practice is starting to take effect
Immigration measures announced as part of Canada's border response to president-elect Donald Trump's 25 per cent tariff threat are starting to be implemented, beginning with a ban on what's known as 'flagpoling.'
Dismiss Trump taunts, expert says after 'churlish' social media posts about Canada
U.S. president-elect Donald Trump and those in his corner continue to send out strong messages about Canada.
Heavy travel day starts with brief grounding of all American Airlines flights
American Airlines briefly grounded flights nationwide Tuesday because of a technical problem just as the Christmas travel season kicked into overdrive and winter weather threatened more potential problems for those planning to fly or drive.
King Charles III is set to focus on healthcare workers in his traditional Christmas message
King Charles III is expected to use his annual Christmas message to highlight health workers, at the end of a year in which both he and the Princess of Wales were diagnosed with cancer.