Laurentian fires back at auditor general, says her demands violate Canadian constitution
Laurentian University has fired the latest shot in its ongoing court battle with Ontario's auditor general.
The sides are involved in a dispute centred on whether LU has an obligation to give the auditor general documents covered by solicitor-client privilege. A hearing is expected to be held in the first two weeks of December.
Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk is conducting a value-for-money audit of Laurentian's books following the university's declaration of insolvency in February. Lysyk argues Section 10 of Ontario's Auditor General Act gives her the right to access to confidential information. Lawyers for LU argue they have the option, but not obligation, to hand over the documents.
In her court filing, Lysyk accused the university of creating a "culture of fear" among staff at the university when it comes to speaking with her staff. And she argued language in the act referring to confidential documents clearly means she has a right to the information.
In response, lawyers for Laurentian took issue with the "culture of fear" comment, saying it rejects the allegation "in the strongest possible terms."
"The auditor general’s allegation was incorrect," Laurentian said in its factum to the Superior Court of Justice.
"The university has provided access to all staff for interviews with the auditor general. The allegation that it has created a 'culture of fear' … appears to be based purely on the university’s direction to its staff that they not disclose privileged information. That direction was entirely appropriate."
Lawyers for Laurentian reject the idea that Lysyk needs access to all privileged information to conduct her audit. They point out that after initially pursuing the information last summer, she then told the university she had changed her mind.
"On Aug. 15, 2021, she formally decided 'not to legally pursue the production of privileged documents,' stating that she would 'conduct her audit using information and documents that she voluntarily receives from Laurentian University,'" the court transcript said.
And they said there is a previous case where she was denied access to privileged documents. When auditing the Attorney General's office in 2019, Lysyk was denied access to files about criminal prosecutions.
"She did not insist on access, and instead used her 'discretion' to deal with the situation with 'a scope limitation,'" the transcript said.
Further, lawyers for Laurentian argued that to force organizations to surrender privileged documents is a major step, and if that was what the province intended, it would have said so explicitly in the legislation.
Instead, they argued the act gives organizations the option to voluntarily surrender those documents, as some provincial organizations have done.
Supreme Court of Canada decisions
To support their arguments, Laurentian points to Supreme Court of Canada decisions that characterize solicitor-client confidentiality as a pillar of the justice system.
"It is indisputable that solicitor-client privilege is fundamental to the proper functioning of our legal system and a cornerstone of access to justice,” one SCC ruling said.
"As a substantive rule, solicitor-client privilege must remain as close to absolute as possible and should not be interfered with unless absolutely necessary,” said another.
In order for it to be lifted, the SCC ruled that language in the legislation "must be explicit and evidence a clear and unambiguous legislative intent to do so."
Language in Section 10 of the Auditor General Act says that if an organization hands over privileged documents, it doesn't constitute a waiver of privilege. Lysyk argues that section means she has the right to that information.
But Laurentian argues there are three pieces of legislation in Ontario in which privileged documents must be handed over; in each case, LU argues the language is explicit.
If that was the intention with the Auditor General Act, the language would be explicit, as well.
"Such language could have been introduced in (Section) 10 of the Auditor General Act, if the Legislature’s intention had truly been to abrogate privilege," the transcript said.
"The auditor general will still have access to all an audit subject’s non-privileged information, including all financial information. This will provide abundant information by which to judge whether public money was properly spent. She will also have access to any privileged information that an audit subject voluntarily provides."
'Flagrant violation'
And Laurentian argues if the act did compel them to surrender privileged documents, it would amount to a "flagrant violation of the Charter of Rights."
Laurentian -- and everyone else -- communicates with lawyers with an expectation of privacy, LU argued. There must be a compelling reason and explicit language in legislation for that right to be removed, something that is not present in this case.
"That expectation of privacy is not diminished by the regulatory context of (Section) 10," the transcript said.
"The reasonable expectation of privacy in information protected by privilege is always high, even though the infringement of privilege arises in a civil, administrative, or regulatory context."
Finally, Laurentian argued the Supreme Court of Canada has ruled that legislation "that interferes with professional secrecy more than is absolutely necessary will be labelled unreasonable."
In this case, Lysyk has demanded confidential information because she has a right to all documents "to inform her work," not because she has proven it is "absolutely necessary."
"In sum, if the auditor general’s interpretation of (Section) 10 is correct, the provision suffers from serious constitutional defects," the transcript said.
"Since the Legislature is presumed to enact constitutional legislation, courts should prefer an interpretation of Section 10 that does not result in a constitutional infringement. This is another reason to prefer the interpretation of (Section) 10 that does not compel the disclosure of privileged information."
Read the entire court filing here.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Canadian gov't proposes new foreign influence registry as part of wide-spanning new bill
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's government is proposing a suite of new measures and law changes aimed at countering foreign interference in Canada, amid extensive scrutiny over past meddling attempts and an ever-evolving threat landscape.
Boeing Starliner capsule's first crewed test flight postponed
The long-awaited first crewed test flight of Boeing's new Starliner space capsule was called off for at least 24 hours over a technical issue that launch teams were unable to resolve in time for the planned Monday night lift-off.
Teacher charged in historical sexual assault of Calgary teenage girl
Calgary police have charged a teacher with the alleged sexual assault of a teenage girl more than 20 years ago.
Winnipeg man admits to killing four women, argues he's not criminally responsible
Defence lawyers of Jeremy Skibicki have admitted in court the accused killed four Indigenous women, but argues he is not criminally responsible for the deaths by way of mental disorder – this latest development has triggered a judge-alone trial rather than a jury trial.
Man banned from owning animals after fatal Calgary dog attack
The owner of three Calgary dogs that got loose and mauled a woman to death in 2022 has been ordered to pay a $15,000 fine within one year and banned from owning any animal for 15 years.
East-end Ottawa family dealing with massive rat infestation
Residents in Ottawa’s Elmridge Gardens complex are dealing with a rat infestation that just won’t go away. Now, after doing everything they can to try to fix the issue, they are pleading with the city to step in and help.
Mediterranean staple may lower your risk of death from dementia, study finds
A daily spoonful of olive oil could lower your risk of dying from dementia, according to a new study by Harvard scientists.
An El Nino-less summer is coming. Here's what that could mean for Canada
As Canadians brace themselves for summer temperatures, forecasters say a weakening El Nino cycle doesn’t mean relief from the heat.
Newfoundland and Labrador latest province to tighten rules on Airbnbs
Newfoundland and Labrador is the latest jurisdiction to bring in stricter rules for short-term rentals, with a coming set of regulations that will force operators to register with the provincial government.