Evidence against Sudbury murder suspect ‘overwhelming,’ Crown tells jury
The Crown prosecutor in Sudbury made his pitch to the jury Monday afternoon in the Robert Steven Wright murder trial, arguing evidence against him is “overwhelming.”
Wright is charged in the stabbing death of Renee Sweeney on Jan. 27, 1998, at Adults Only Video in a strip mall on Paris Street.
“Robert Steven Wright murdered Renee Sweeney,” Crown prosecutor Rob Parsons told the 13 jurors, before rebutting many of the arguments the defence made in its closing arguments in the morning.
Defence attorney Michael Lacy presented an alternate suspect, John Fetterly, who was originally charged with the crime in February 1998 and then released.
Fetterly was obsessed with knives, jurors were told, and was charged with stealing pornography magazines not long after Sweeney’s death.
Porn magazines were also stolen at the Sweeney crime scene. Parsons said that appears to be incriminating, but it’s not.
“There’s absolutely no real physical or scientific evidence that supports the bald assertion that John Fetterly killed Renee Sweeney or that he was even in Sudbury,” he said.
Witness Ray Hutchinson did pick Fetterly out of a photo lineup, identifying him as the person he saw enter the video store sometime between 10:45 am and 11 a.m.
But Parsons said Hutchinson admitted to seeing the person for just “a fraction of a second” and the person he saw could have been the person who made a final purchase at 10:46 a.m., before Sweeney was killed sometime between 11 a.m. and 11:30 a.m.
“John Fetterly is a distraction,” Parsons said.
“Nothing, zero, comes back to John Fetterly.”
He said a witness puts him at his residence in Mildmay a night or two before the murder, 400 kilometres away. Fetterly didn’t drive and would normally come to town with his parents or take a bus.
Parsons then showed pictures of Fetterly taken after his arrest that don’t show any signs of injuries.
“His hands have no wounds,” he said.
While he was sure the defence was happy to hear he had been arrested for stealing porn magazines, Parsons said the cases were different.
Robert Steven Wright, seen in photos close to the time of Renee Sweeney's murder in January 1998, is on trial for second-degree murder in Sudbury. (File)
In that case, Fetterly was drunk and the clerk knew who he was. He grabbed magazines and he’s “so drunk he’s on the sidewalk outside store,” with the magazines falling everywhere.
He was almost immediately arrested and no violence was involved.
“John Fetterly had nothing to do with the murder,” Parsons said.
He then turned his attention to Wright, saying he and the jury have almost no idea “who Robert Steven Wright is.”
We know he was a boy scout with a motto of “be prepared,” Parsons said.
“The evidence before us is that Robert Steven Wright was prepared to take a life -- very prepared to take a life – very prepared to flee and prepared to hide evidence.”
He drew the jury’s attention to the young couple who discovered Wright hunched over Sweeney’s body. They gave a detailed description of Wright, Parsons said, leading to the composite sketch that closely resembled him.
Both of their names are covered by a publication ban.
The male witness in the case said Wright “was grabbing something and shoving it into some sort of bag,” Parsons said.
“What’s in the bag?”
This is photo of the stained teal jacket that Brian McRury and his canine Oakey discovered during the track on Jan. 27, 1998. (Supplied)
How could someone come across a “horrific” situation, Parsons said, insist he was in shock but then be gathering something?
Both of the witnesses said there appeared to be something in the bag – it was bulging and stretched, like there were boxes inside.
“This is completely contradictory” to Wright’s evidence, Parsons said.
The male witness also said he saw Sweeney move her head to the right. Parsons pointed to evidence from pathologist Kelly Uren, who said Sweeney’s neck muscles were severed so she couldn’t move her head and would have bled out in a minute or two – and no more than five.
The fact the witness saw Sweeney move means she was still alive and had been stabbed within a few minutes, Parsons argued.
“That is incredibly powerful evidence from someone who observed it,” he said.
“Renee Sweeney is alive when (the male witness) sees her. She’s alive. Her head moves to the right.”
While Uren testified that with her neck muscles severed, it would be “near impossible” to move to the right – but not impossible.
SWEENEY FOUGHT BACK
“There is clear and compelling evidence that Renee Sweeney did many things to try and save her life,” Parsons said.
There’s no reason to think that one of her final acts “would have been any less remarkable.”
Parsons argued that Wright stabbed Sweeney, removed his jacket and gloves, went to the washroom to clean up, found Sweeney was still alive and was finishing her off when he was discovered.
Wright cleaned himself up “as much as he could – his face, his neck and his hands,” Parsons said, but couldn’t clean the jacket or the bloodstained gloves.
He also took issue with Wright’s recollection of events – crystal clear at some points, blank in others. For example, he remembers touching Sweeney’s shoulder and checking her pulse, but doesn’t remember where he fell back or what he braced himself on when he felt faint.
And nothing in his testimony, Parsons said, explained why a significant amount of his DNA got on Sweeney’s fingernails.
A few seconds of contact with her wrist isn’t likely to leave that much DNA on Sweeney’s fingernails, he said.
So it’s a “flight of fancy to suggest it got there through casual contact or contamination,” Parsons said.
Wright’s explanation for how his fingerprints got on the cashbox is also hard to understand, he said. Wright said he braced himself on something, yet his fingerprint was found under the cash tray and another on one of the change slots.
“I submit to you, that makes no sense,” Parsons said.
“We do know there’s $178.25 missing from the one area we know Robert Steven Wright touched.”
'WHY TAKE THE JACKET?'
Wright testified he fled the crime scene in a state of panic, yet he not only grabs his jacket and gloves first, he also cuts behind the video store after first running up Paris Street.
“Why take the jacket … if job No. 1 was to run as fast as you can?” Parsons asked.
As he passed witnesses, Parsons said Wright didn’t yell to them to call an ambulance, but instead made his way to Nepahwin Avenue and discarded evidence.
“There never was a panic, there was flight,” Parsons said.
“Panic is a useful fiction by Robert Steven Wright to explain why he didn’t do what anybody would do in that situation unless they are guilty.”
A person in panic might run across Paris Street without stopping, he said. Instead, Wright chose “an almost perfect path to allow him to escape.”
As for the porn magazines and sex toys that were taken, Parsons said Wright could have disposed of them anywhere, “but we don’t know.”
He also asked the jury to consider the amount of blood found on Wright’s jacket and gloves – the gloves in particular had a lot of blood on them.
Parsons argued that the amount of blood is not consistent with Wright’s testimony that he only touched Sweeney’s shoulder and checked her pulse.
After washing up, Parsons said Wright was ready to flee when he was discovered in the store.
ATTACKED IN THREE AREAS
The evidence is that Sweeney was attacked in three distinct areas of the store—and that she fought back.
Sweeney’s left hand was nearly severed with a defensive wound, Parsons said, while she used her right hand to scratch her attacker and get his DNA under her fingernails.
“Renee’s left hand has no DNA on it,” Parsons said, adding that Sweeney was sending a message about who killed her.
“Her right hand was also busy” trying to get evidence of her killer, “and she succeeded,” he said.
The next stage in the trial is instructions to the jury from Justice Robbie Gordon, which will happen beginning Tuesday morning.
The jurors will then begin their deliberations.
CTVNewsNorthernOntario.ca continues to follow the trial from inside the courtroom and will provide updates Tuesday afternoon.
Find all of the previous coverage of the murder trial here.
The brutal stabbing death of 23-year-old Renee Sweeney rocked the City of Sudbury to its core on Jan. 27, 1998.
Police searched for her killer for two decades and finally charged Robert Steven Wright, who was 18 years old at the time of the murder. He has been held in jail since his arrest in Dec. 2018.
After several delays, the trial began Feb. 21, 2023, just after the 25th anniversary of Sweeney's death.
CTV News Digital content producer Darren MacDonald is bringing the latest from the courtroom every day and will have full coverage of the trial here.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Humanity at risk: AI pioneer urges federal government to regulate faster
One of the so-called godfathers of artificial intelligence says governments need to move faster on regulations to protect against the dangers of the rapidly advancing technology, before it poses a larger threat to humanity.
Running through middle age can keep brain healthy and neurons wired: study
Exercising as you age can help maintain memory and fight cognitive decline, according to a new study.
Prediabetes: The younger you are, the higher the risk of dementia
People who develop prediabetes when they’re younger are likely to have a higher risk for dementia in later life, a new U.S. study has found.
'We have an influence': How some Canadians are inspiring others to focus on the environment
From actions in their local communities to mass demonstrations, here's how Canadians from all walks of life are inspiring others to take part in helping the environment.
Hamilton police ask residents to shelter after barricaded man involved in double homicide fires shots
Police in Hamilton, Ont. are dealing with a barricaded person who they say is involved in the deaths of two people.
GOP-controlled Texas House impeaches Republican Attorney General Ken Paxton, triggering suspension
Texas' Republican-led House of Representatives impeached state Attorney General Ken Paxton on Saturday on articles including bribery and abuse of public trust, a sudden, historic rebuke of a GOP official who rose to be a star of the conservative legal movement despite years of scandal and alleged crimes.
Dellandrea scores twice in 3rd, Stars stay alive with 4-2 victory over Golden Knights
Ty Dellandrea scored twice in a 1:27 span midway through the third period and the Dallas Stars beat the Vegas Golden Knights 4-2 on Saturday night to stay alive in the Western Conference Final.
Team Canada hockey players Marie-Philip Poulin and Laura Stacey engaged
Celebrated Team Canada hockey players Marie-Philip Poulin and Laura Stacey have announced their engagement.
Attorney for 11-year-old Mississippi boy shot by police says there's 'no way' he could have been mistaken for an adult
An attorney for an 11-year-old Mississippi boy who was shot by a police officer after he called 911 for help said Thursday there was 'no way' the boy could have been mistaken for an adult.
All cats rescued, donations needed after fire at Oro-Medonte animal shelter
After a devastating fire at an Oro-Medonte animal shelter, all missing cats have been accounted for.
Ontario police reveal new development in Elnaz Hajtamiri abduction investigation
Ontario Provincial Police arrested a fourth suspect in connection to the alleged kidnapping of Elnaz Hajtamiri, the Ontario woman who disappeared in January 2022.
4 people hospitalized trying to rescue cats in Oro-Medonte shelter fire
Several people have been hospitalized with smoke inhalation after trying to save multiple animals from a fire at a cat shelter on Shanty Bay Road in Oro-Medonte.
BREAKING | SIU investigating after two people killed in Stoney Creek
Ontario’s Special Investigation Unit (SIU) has been called following an interaction with a man believed to be responsible for a double homicide in Stoney Creek.
Victim rushed to hospital following early morning stabbing in downtown Toronto
One person was rushed to hospital following an early morning stabbing in downtown Toronto.
Animal advocates call for alternatives to coyotes, foxes in Ontario dog training areas
Advocates are hoping the Ontario government will consider alternatives to the use of wild animals in off-leash dog areas for the purpose of tracking as officials push forward with a proposal to expand training areas in the province.
A hot and sunny Sunday in Ottawa
It's going to be hot and sunny in Ottawa as the annual marathon and half-marathon take over downtown streets.
Ottawa to begin spraying and mowing wild parsnip in suburban and rural areas
The city of Ottawa will begin spraying and mowing roadsides, pathways and parks this week to deal with wild parsnip, the invasive plant that can cause skin and eye irritation and make the skin prone to burning and blistering.
Mayoral run: Ottawa mayor exceeds marathon fundraiser goal for housing project
Ottawa mayor Mark Sutcliffe has raised more than $25,000 toward repairs to a local supportive facility that was severely damaged by a February flood.
Three-vehicle crash in Wellington County leaves one dead
One person has died following a three vehicle crash on Highway 6 in Wellington County.
Man arrested for attempted murder, another seriously hurt in Kitchener shooting
The Waterloo Regional Police Service has arrested a man for attempted murder after a shooting in Kitchener left another man with serious injuries.
‘These issues are still here’: Advocates speak out following unhoused experience event in Victoria Park
A 24-hour camp out in Victoria Park, meant to highlight the homelessness crisis, has come to an end.
Free parking to now cost $200 per month as Webster St. apartment ‘renoviction’ saga continues
There is a new chapter in the “renoviction” saga at Webster Street apartments in London, Ont.
Vehicle crashes into house, severs gas line
A large emergency response was seen in the north end of London, Ont. Friday night after a driver allegedly ran their truck into a house.
Taking steps to help combat cognitive loss
Walks were held across the London region Saturday, raising funds to support programs and services offered by the Alzheimer Societies.
One person in hospital following collision involving motorcycle
A motorcycle rider is in hospital with serious injuries following a sing-vehicle collision Saturday afternoon.
Fire crews battle blaze in the city's east end
Wyandotte Street East between Lawrence Road and Raymo Road has reopened following a fire in the area.
Fatal collision devastates a community, youth hockey player charged with assault, teen charged in gun incident: Top Windsor stories this week
A devastating collision end the lives of three young adults, a Windsor dad said he’s frustrated his 12-year-old son has been charged with assault, and a teenager was arrested for allegedly bringing a gun to school.
'Pay attention': Family of struck Montreal 10 year old pleads with motorists to drive safely
The family of a 10-year-old girl who was hit by a car almost two weeks ago is appealing drivers and pedestrians to be more careful on Montreal’s roads. Kyaa Guinto is still in a coma at the Montreal Children’s Hospital. “She’s slowly come out of the induced coma, she’s moving her hands, she was able to squeeze our hands, and we’re waiting patiently,” said her mother, Stephanie Ledesma.
Quebec trucker subdues runaway injured horse on Highway 40
Quebecers are used to congestion headaches on Highway 40, but Saturday’s hold-up was nothing if not out of the ordinary: a horse broke free from its transport container and ran free in the fast lane. Marco Lelievre, a trucker, stopped his vehicle while driving through Repentigny, Que. after he saw the runaway horse.
Second Montreal business targeted by arson attack this weekend
A Montreal business was targeted by an arson attack for the second day in a row, this time in the Ahuntsic-Cartierville borough. Police say a 911 call was made just before 5 a.m. Sunday. By the time SPVM officers arrived, firefighters had put out the flames at the bakery on Charles de la Tour Street, near Antonio-Barbeau Street.
Wildfire near Goose Lake, N.S. burning out of control
A sizeable wildfire is burning out of control in Shelburne County, Nova Scotia.
N.B. premier calls for calm amid review of policy on sexual orientation in schools
New Brunswick's premier is calling for calm as the province launches a contentious review of a policy on sexual orientation in schools.
Man shot and killed by police in Dartmouth, HRP refer shooting to SiRT
A man is dead after being shot by police in Dartmouth during an incident Saturday morning.
RCMP investigating possible drowning at Whiteshell Provincial Park
A Winnipeg boy may have drowned at Whiteshell Provincial Park, according to RCMP.
'Right tree, right place': The work Winnipeg is doing to restore its tree canopy
The City of Winnipeg’s annual push to restore its tree canopy is underway.
Five fire departments respond to Friday night scrapyard blaze
Firefighters in the RM of Springfield were busy Friday night, taking on a scrapyard fire involving molten metal into the early morning hours.
Alberta NDP holds rally in Calgary, UCP talks about crime, mental health supports
Alberta NDP Leader Rachel Notley held a major rally in downtown Calgary Saturday morning, while her United Conservative rival had no public events planned this weekend after a final pitch to voters a day earlier.
Police seeking information regarding Friday night hit-and-run in northeast Calgary
Calgary police are investigating a hit-and-run in the northeast community of Renfrew.
Wildfire danger remains high in northern Alberta, but firefighters making progress
The number of wildfires burning in Alberta's protected forest areas has continued to drop.
Wildfire danger remains high in northern Alberta, but firefighters making progress
The number of wildfires burning in Alberta's protected forest areas has continued to drop.
'It was just adorable': Grade 1 students surprise departing firefighters with special goodbye gifts
An Edmonton Grade 1 class was at the Edmonton International Airport Saturday to give a crew of wildland firefighters handmade thank-you cards and wish them well on their way back to New Brunswick.
'More connected': Researchers looking at growing food under solar panels
Lawns, backyards and roofs could be used to produce both solar power and fresh vegetables, University of Alberta researchers say.
‘A crime of passion’: Bizarre B.C. bakery break-in caught on camera
The owner of a cake shop in Vancouver’s Dunbar neighbourhood braced for the worst when she found her store had been broken into Friday morning. But what she found captured by a security camera was a break-in beyond her wildest imagination.
Brazen shooting prompts Mounties to host public outreach event
Ten days after shots rang out at a busy Coquitlam shopping complex in broad daylight, Coquitlam RCMP held a public outreach event to address public concerns.
Several multiple sclerosis drugs covered by Pharmacare in every province except B.C.
Deborah Stefanek's doctor recommended she take a new medication called Kisempta to treat her relapsing remitting multiple sclerosis. She was shocked to learn every province in Canada covers Kisempta under their Pharmacare plans except B.C.