Hoggard takes stand in sex assault trial, denies that he raped complainant
-- WARNING -- The following details of the sexual assault case may be disturbing, discretion is advised.
Canadian musician Jacob Hoggard took the stand in his sexual assault trial on Tuesday, denying that he raped his accuser and painting a dramatically different picture of their encounter eight years ago.
Wearing a dark suit, Hoggard told a jury that he and the complainant in the case had a consensual one-night stand in Kirkland Lake, Ont., after his then-band Hedley performed a show.
Justice Robin Tremblay, left to right, Assistant Crown Attorney Peter Keen, Crown Attorney Lilly Gates, Hoggard's lawyers Kally Ho, Megan Savard and Hoggard are shown in a courtroom sketch in Haileybury, Ont., Sept. 23, 2024. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Alexandra Newbould
As defence lawyer Megan Savard took him through his recollections of the encounter, she asked whether it had been consensual.
"Of course it was," he said.
She asked what about the sex allows Hoggard to now say so confidently that it was consensual.
"Well, she was as into it as I was," he said, adding that the complainant was positioned on top of him for "quite a bit" of the session.
"I remember her moaning and saying yes and a lot of kissing while she was on top of me."
The complainant, during four days of emotional testimony last week, had told a completely different story.
The Crown and defence agree that a sexual encounter between the two happened in Hoggard's hotel room following a bonfire the band hosted nearby after their concert.
Prosecutors are seeking to prove it was not consensual. The complainant, who repeatedly said she did not consent to the sex, was the Crown's only witness.
The woman, who was 19 years old at the time and whose name is protected by a publication ban, denied every suggestion during Savard's cross-examination that she wanted to have sex with Hoggard or that they had flirted beforehand.
- Download the CTV News app now
- Get local breaking news alerts
- Daily newsletter with the top local stories emailed to your inbox
On Tuesday, Savard showed the court a tour itinerary and had Hoggard mark the location of the bonfire, which he said he built, on a printed aerial photo of the hotel.
He said he arrived to build the fire with another band member before others arrived, contradicting the complainant's testimony that they were in a van together headed to the party.
He said he first noticed her sitting cross-legged by the fire, found her attractive and wanted to talk to her.
"At some point I had my hand on her leg, and I remember just laughing with her and joking around and kind of just flirting," he said.
"She seemed to be having a great time."
He said they exchanged phone numbers, and at one point, he texted her asking if she wanted to spend the night with him. Later, he said, they kissed and held hands.
Savard asked if he mentioned they would play music in his room or have "casual conversation," words the complainant used in her testimony to characterize his invitation to stay. He said no.
When they got into his hotel room, Hoggard said he played some songs on his guitar. His accuser had strongly denied that this could have happened.
He said they kissed before helping each other undress and then had sex. He denied that the woman struggled, that he hit or choked her, that he pinned her down, that she ever said she was uncomfortable and that he called her a "dirty little pig" as she had described in court.
He also denied telling her, as the complainant testified, that she shouldn't be concerned about sexually transmitted diseases because he "picks them young," or that she shouldn't worry about his girlfriend at the time finding out about it.
Hoggard testified that he and his now-wife were broken up at the time. Savard showed the jury several pieces of documentation suggesting that they weren't together.
That included an Instagram post his now-wife posted a couple of days before the Kirkland Lake show, with the caption: "And then she gave zero cares." Hoggard said he took this as a sign she was "moving on."
Savard also showed court a screenshot of an email that Hoggard's now-wife sent him several days after the concert, asking why he had changed his phone number.
The defence lawyer told the jury in her opening statement on Tuesday morning that she expected to call two more witnesses in her case -- both members of the crew who worked the Hedley concert that night. Savard suggested the two would contradict further elements of the complainant's account.
Hoggard, who told court he began working as a carpenter after Hedley broke up in 2018 and is now living "hand to mouth," was expected to continue his testimony later on Tuesday.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Oct. 1, 2024.
Background
Jacob Hoggard was charged in 2022 for an alleged sexual assault in Kirkland Lake on June 25, 2016.
His former band had performed the night before at the small town's homecoming festival.
In December 2022, he elected to be tried by a jury rather than by a judge alone.
Fourteen jurors were selected Monday, including two alternates. The two alternates were dismissed as the testimony got underway.
Tremblay is presiding over the trial at the Haileybury courthouse.
The case is being prosecuted by Crown Attorney Lilly Gates and Assistant Crown Attorney Peter Keen while Hoggard is being defended by attorneys Megan Savard and Kally Ho.
Ontario Provincial Police Sgt. Dalton Crockett, the lead investigator in the case, is sitting behind the Crown attorney's table and expects to be present throughout the trial.
Hoggard stood up in court Monday morning and pled not guilty to the sexual assault charges.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
'We are in for more terrorism, not less,' warns Canadian terror expert amid Syria's political chaos
The collapse of Bashar al-Assad’s regime means the ticking time bomb of prisons holding thousands of suspected ISIS members in northeast Syria has become even more unstable, a Canadian terrorism expert warns.
Settlement reached in complaint over Canada Post layoffs as strike hits four weeks
The union representing Canada Post workers says an unfair labour practice complaint over the company's layoffs has been resolved.
Banks tell 2 Ontarians too much time has passed to cash decades-old cheque, GIC
Two Ontarians who recently found unclaimed money from decades-old investments were told by their banks there were no records of them in their systems.
Ontario Premier Doug Ford threatens to cut off energy to U.S. in response to Trump's tariffs
Ontario Premier Doug Ford has threatened to cut off energy supply to the U.S. in response to the tariffs President-elect Donald Trump plans to impose on all Canadian imports.
Missing 'lost Canadians' deadline creates 'unknowable' number of new citizens: feds
The federal government is asking an Ontario Superior Court for more time to pass citizenship legislation for the "lost Canadians," saying that without an extension an "unknowable" number of people would automatically become citizens next week.
Rescue group saves 11-year-old girl floating alone in the Mediterranean for days after shipwreck
An 11-year-old girl from Sierra Leone was found floating in the Mediterranean Sea off Italy's southernmost island of Lampedusa, believed to be the only survivor of a shipwrecked migrant boat that had departed from the port of Sfax in Tunisia, a humanitarian group said Thursday.
Elon Musk calls Justin Trudeau 'insufferable tool' in new social media post
Billionaire Elon Musk is calling Prime Minister Justin Trudeau 'an insufferable tool' in a new social media post on Wednesday. 'Won't be in power for much longer,' Musk also wrote about the prime minister on 'X.'
More than 60,000 customers without power in the Maritimes due to wet, windy storm
Tens of thousands of customers in the Maritimes woke up to no power Thursday morning and several schools are closed as a wet and windy storm makes its way through the region.
Air Canada to offer free Wi-Fi on flights for Aeroplan members, sponsored by Bell
Air Canada plans to offer free Wi-Fi to Aeroplan members aboard its flights starting next year, building on a partnership with telecom giant Bell that already gives passengers free text messaging capabilities.