Controversial Sudbury roads project was halted because of problems with the asphalt, investigation concludes
Sudbury’s auditor general is refuting allegations from a road resurfacing company that levelled several personal accusations against city staff who halted work on a project this summer.
Ron Foster said he received formal complaints from Frank Crupi of Toronto-based Road Surface Recycling in July, when the city halted the work.
Foster said he narrowed the list down by removing repetitive complaints and ones that were too personal. But of the nine he investigated, he said there was no evidence that city staff stopped the project for any reason other than job performance.
The pilot project used hot-in-place recycling and was supposed to extend the life of the section of road on the Kingsway at a much lower cost.
After the project was shut down, Crupi made several allegations about city staff at a town hall meeting Sept. 7. He said there was no valid reason to halt the project and that the city staffers in charge were not qualified.
Foster said his investigation is being made public because Crupi went public with his accusations. He said the complaints he investigated include:
-- Was there a lack of qualifications and objectivity to examine the work?
-- Did an agenda exist at city hall to see this pilot project fail?
Ron Foster said he received formal complaints from Frank Crupi of Toronto-based Road Surface Recycling in July, when the city halted the work. (Photo from video)
-- Was it unfair to force RSR to wait four weeks for testing results?
-- Allegations that the testing of the work was not necessary
-- And that the stop work order not made in good faith or spirit of co-operation.
He said the first thing he looked into was whether there was a valid reason to stop the work.
"Was it warranted? Was it justified?” Foster said.
“Did the city have objective criteria? Did the city have an objective process that was properly administered in fairness to all parties?"
He said the evidence from internal and third-party testing of the asphalt showed it wasn’t up to the standard called for in the contract with the city.
"DOCUMENTS REALLY TOLD A DIFFERENT STORY'
"The documents really told a different story,” Foster said.
“Those documents included contract documents and field inspection notes and documentation about the performance of RSR during paving."
While Crupi aimed his criticism at the female managers working on the project, Foster said the decision to halt the work was a collective one.
“We concluded that … the decision to issue a stop work order, it wasn’t the decision of an individual, it was a collective decision by the team administering the contract,” he said.
“The team had no fewer than seven individuals and they were all competent with decades of experience.”
In addition to Foster’s report, three city councillors who attended the Sept. 7 public meeting are being investigated by the city’s integrity commissioner.
Read the full report here.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
B.C. election results: NDP gains ground in latest release of mail-in ballot data
Elections BC released its first partial results of the final count in B.C.'s 2024 provincial election Saturday afternoon, and the data shows NDP candidates gaining in some tight races.
Ontario man tells police he harmed two family members, three found dead
Huntsville OPP and the Special Investigations Unit (SIU) are conducting a homicide investigation after three individuals were found dead in a Huntsville neighbourhood Friday evening.
Trump refers to CNN's Anderson Cooper by a woman's first name
Former U.S. president Donald Trump has repeatedly referred to CNN anchor Anderson Cooper with a woman's first name in recent days as the Republican presidential nominee focuses his closing message on a hypermasculine appeal to men.
Lawsuit alleges Ontario man died after given 10 times prescribed dose in hospital
Angela Salvatore had been away from her father's hospital bedside for just over an hour when she says she got a frantic call from a nurse, pleading with her to calm him down.
15-year-old found dead in eastern Ontario, teen facing second-degree murder charge: OPP
Ontario Provincial Police say a 16-year-old has been charged with second-degree murder after a 15-year-old was found dead at a home in Perth, Ont. Friday afternoon.
Lizzo's Halloween costume draws inspiration from 'South Park' episode that referenced her and the weight-loss drug Ozempic
Lizzo has taken a rather silly reference to her on a recent 'South Park' episode and elevated it to a hilarious Halloween costume.
What we know about the Canadians busted in an international drug ring led by a former Olympic athlete
Canadian Ryan James Wedding finished in 24th place in the parallel giant slalom at the 2002 Winter Games in Salt Lake City, but the snowboarder wouldn’t go on to improve his results in Torino four years later.
Ottawa journalist says claims that he is a Russian agent are 'fabricated'
A veteran Ottawa journalist is firing back against what he says are "entirely false" claims by a former Conservative cabinet minister that he acted as a Russian agent.
Israel's first open attack on Iran targets missile sites and apparently spares oil and nuclear ones
Israel attacked military targets in Iran with pre-dawn airstrikes Saturday in retaliation for the barrage of ballistic missiles the Islamic Republic fired on Israel earlier this month. It was the first time Israel's military has openly attacked Iran.