Sudbury cardiologist loses bid to have hospital privileges restored
A prominent cardiologist in Sudbury who brought a less invasive operating method to the north has lost his latest court battle to have his hospital privileges restored at Health Sciences North.
Dr. Dinkar Shukla made headlines in 2014 when he brought the transcatheter aortic valve implantation (TAVI) procedure to Sudbury. It allows the aortic valve to be replaced without first having to remove the old one.
While much less invasive, the operation is complex and requires a team of doctors.
“TAVI is a complicated procedure that carries significant risks for the patient,” said the transcript of the court case.
“It requires a team of physicians typically including nurses, technicians, a cardiologist, an anaesthetist, and a cardiovascular surgeon.”
Shukla has practised medicine in the city since 2008 and operates his own cardiac practise for his patients. In order to remain credentialed, surgeons have to perform a minimum number of the operations per year.
According to the court transcript, problems began in 2018 when two additional TAVI doctors arrived at HSN.
“The evidence before the hospital board suggests that Dr. Shukla enjoyed a collaborative and professional relationship with other medical staff until two new transcatheter aortic valve implanters arrived in 2018,” the transcript said.
“Within a few months of two additional TAVI doctors arriving at the hospital, conflicts developed. Those conflicts mushroomed into four-plus years’ worth of medical-legal proceedings over questions of interpersonal conflict, patient care, fairness, hospital leadership, respect for colleagues, reputation, and professionalism, with inevitable costs to the hospital, their colleagues and the community.”
In May 2020, HSN’s medical advisory committee informed Shukla that his hospital privileges were being revoked. That led to appeal hearings beginning in January 2021 by the hospital board, which heard evidence and submissions on Shukla’s case over 15 days.
When the board confirmed the decision, Shukla appealed to the Health Professions Appeal and Review Board to restore his hospital privileges.
When the board refused in July 2022, he applied for a judicial review of the decision. The judicial review hearing is scheduled for May 10, 2023.
At the same time, Shukla applied to the court to restore his hospital privileges while the judicial review is pending. His lawyer’s arguments included the fact that his medical competence wasn’t being called into question.
“Rather, Dr. Shukla was a senior member of a six-member interventional cardiologist team at Health Sciences North, where his skills can serve the community at a time where health care in Ontario is stretched,” the transcript said.
“Dr. Shukla continued to work in the hospital throughout the lengthy hearing before the hospital board. The emergency procedures could have been invoked if there were issues of risk to patients or competence.”
In response, HSN said there were broader issues at play.
'HEALTH SCIENCES NORTH DOES NOT AGREE'
“Health Sciences North does not agree,” the transcript said.
“It submits that after the hearing, the hospital board found that Dr. Shukla’s misconduct was related to the conflicts among the TAVI team, and that Dr. Shukla chose to mislead patients, colleagues and other doctors, rather than work honestly and collaboratively. This behaviour undermined his colleagues and put patient care and safety at risk.”
The court ruled that while many factors in the case will be adjudicated during the judicial appeal, HSN submits that patient care would be affected if Shukla’s privileges were restored.
“The hospital board found that patient care and safety was put at risk, given the strength and cohesiveness required in highly specialized, high-risk team environments such as the one to which Dr. Shukla formerly belonged,” the transcript said.
“However, there is also Dr. Shukla’s prior record for collegiality, professionalism and his competence and skill in interventional cardiology and TAVI procedures. It may well be that the findings and catalyst for these proceedings relate more to a combination of situational factors, unlikely to be replicated. However, that is not my decision to make.”
In addition to ruling in favour of HSN, Shukla was also ordered to pay the hospital’s legal costs of $45,000.
Read the full transcript here.
Correction
Cardiologist Dr. Shukla was incorrectly referred to as a heart surgeon in the initial publication.
The transcatheter aortic valve implantation is a procedure that involves inserting a catheter into the leg or chest and guiding it to the heart and not considered surgery as initially reported.
The article above has been corrected.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Grandparent scam: London, Ont., senior beats fraudsters not once, but twice
It was a typical Tuesday for Mabel Beharrell, 84, until she got the call that would turn her world upside down. Her teenaged grandson was in trouble and needed her help.
Deaths of 4 people on Sask. farm confirmed as murder-suicide
The deaths of four people on a farm near the Saskatchewan village of Neudorf have been confirmed a murder-suicide.
CRA no longer requiring 'bare trust' reporting in 2023 tax return
The Canada Revenue Agency announced Thursday it will not require 'bare trust' reporting from Canadians that it introduced for the 2024 tax season, just four days before the April 2 deadline.
Full parole granted to man convicted in notorious 'McDonald's murders' in Cape Breton
The Parole Board of Canada has granted full parole to one of three men convicted in the brutal murders of three McDonald's restaurant workers in Cape Breton more than 30 years ago.
Incident on Calgary's Reconciliation Bridge comes to safe resolution
Nearly 20 hours after a man climbed and remained perched on top of the Reconciliation Bridge in downtown Calgary, the situation came to a peaceful resolution.
Sunshine list: These were the Ontario public sector's highest earners in 2023
Ontario released its annual sunshine list Thursday afternoon, noting that the largest year-over-year increases were in hospitals, municipalities, and post-secondary sectors.
George Washington family secrets revealed by DNA from unmarked 19th century graves
Genetic analysis has shed light on a long-standing mystery surrounding the fates of U.S. President George Washington's younger brother Samuel and his kin.
'We won't forget': How some Muslims view Poilievre's stance on Israel-Hamas war
A spokesman for a regional Muslim advocacy group says Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre's stance on the Israel-Hamas war could complicate his party's relationship with Muslim Canadians.
Why some Christians are angry about Trump's 'God Bless the USA' Bible
Former U.S. President Donald Trump is officially selling a copy of the Bible themed to Lee Greenwood’s famous song, 'God Bless the USA.' But the concept of a Bible covered in the American flag has raised concern among religious circles.