Stab wounds to Sudbury murder victim’s neck were fatal blows, pathologist testifies
Warning: This story describes the autopsy of a murder victim and contains many details some people will find upsetting.
The forensic pathologist who conducted the autopsy on Sudbury murder victim Renee Sweeney testified Thursday that a series of four wounds to her neck proved to be the fatal blows.
Dr. Kelly Uren was testifying at the trial of Robert Steven Wright, who is charged with second-degree murder in Sweeney’s Jan. 27, 1998, death.
In response to a question from Crown prosecutor Rob Parsons, Uren said the autopsy began at 9:47 a.m. on Jan. 28, a day after the murder.
It was conducted in North Bay because at the time, there was no one qualified to do it in Sudbury.
The exterior of Sweeney’s remains was examined first. That examination provides an “overall impression of the general health of the person and any external injuries … that may be present,” he said.
Uren said he noted a total of 27 wounds, including to the abdomen, neck, upper chest and hands. He said there were five cuts in the T-shirt Sweeney wore the day she was killed.
He described most of the wounds as serious but not life-threatening by themselves. For example, there was a stab wound that pierced 8 ½ inches into her abdomen.
“In and of itself, it was not life-threatening,” Uren said, but added that “it would bleed a lot.”
“There’s (also) a slash or cut on the thumb, with a deeper one right across the palm.”
There were also a series of stab wounds to her chest – about five – that were not very deep.
“None of the wounds penetrated the chest cavity,” he said.
Two more wounds were found on the left side of the neck, Uren said -- one just above the hairline, the other below the earlobe.
There were significant wounds to the right cheek and another large wound at the base of the right side of the neck
“This wound is somewhat more significant,” Uren testified.
It appeared to be from a series of four blows and resulted in the carotid artery being partially severed.
“The extent of those injuries, and the multiple cuts, leads it to being a more significant injury,” he said.
“This is the injury leading to death.”
Uren explained there are two carotid arteries, one on each side of the neck.
“They carry a considerable amount of blood” to the brain, he said.
“The carotid artery was partially transected.”
If the artery had been completely severed, Uren said there was a better chance of stopping the bleeding because the body would respond to try and close the artery.
But that’s not what happens when the artery is partially cut.
“It can bleed more than a completely transected (artery),” Uren said.
Renee Sweeney was a 23-year-old student at Laurentian University who worked as a part-time clerk at Adults Only Video. She was stabbed to death while working at the store sometime between 11 a.m. and 11:30 a.m. on Jan. 27, 1998. (File)
Other wounds cut into the jugular vein and Sweeney’s trachea. Combined, he said the wounds would have led to massive blood loss in a very quick time period.
He estimated there would be maybe a minute or two of “voluntary conscious movement” by the victim before shock and blood loss set in.
“Take it with a grain of salt” he added, of the time estimate, because there could be several variables.
But in response to a question from Parsons, Uren said it’s hard to picture a scenario in which the victim is conscious for more than four or five minutes.
“I would be very surprised if someone could physically resist after five minutes with a wound like this,” he said.
“In two minutes, she could conceivably have lost more than a litre of blood. That’s 10 per cent of her blood … Five minutes of active struggle? I doubt it.”
Sweeney likely wouldn’t have a pulse within four or five minutes, he added.
“I suspect probably less,” Uren said.
“A pulse requires working bodily fluid.”
Uren said he couldn’t offer many specifics about the blade used in the killing. He said “hilt marks” can sometimes be seen when a full blade enters the body and the top of the handle leaves a mark.
UNSURE ABOUT THE KNIFE
But the clothes Sweeney wore likely would have prevented hilt marks from being visible.
“It was a relatively stout blade,” he said, adding it was roughly two centimetres wide. The deepest wound was 8 ½ inches.
In response to a question from defence attorney Michal Lacy, Uren explained that a severed artery doesn’t “spray” in a way often shown in movies and TV.
“When an artery is cut … it’s not a spray that will cover everything,” he said.
It’s more of a surge or a “pulse of blood” that would rapidly diminish as blood pressure drops.
Uren also said that a muscle in Sweeney’s neck was cut – the muscle that allows people to turn their heads to the right.
“So she could no longer turn to the right?” Lacy asked.
It would be difficult but not impossible, Uren replied, adding it would be almost impossible.
He had testified earlier that he was the one that clipped Sweeney’s fingernails to be preserved in bags as evidence. But Lacy pointed out that former forensics officer Leo Thibeault testified Wednesday that he had clipped the fingernails, not Uren.
“Would that be a complete shock to you?” Lacy asked.
“No,” Uren responded.
“I can’t say I remember actually doing the clipping. I remember holding the hands.”
Lacy suggested it was a matter of believing he had a strong memory of something that happened a long time ago, then realizing it was a false memory when prompted with what actually happened.
“Absolutely,” Uren said.
The trial ended for the day after Uren’s testimony and will resume Monday morning, where CTV News' coverage will continue.
Background
The brutal stabbing death of 23-year-old Renee Sweeney rocked the City of Sudbury to its core on Jan. 27, 1998.
Police searched for her killer for two decades and finally charged Robert Steven Wright, who was 18 years old at the time of the murder. He has been held in jail since his arrest in Dec. 2018.
After several delays, the trial began Feb. 21, 2023, just after the 25th anniversary of Sweeney's death.
CTV News Digital content producer Darren MacDonald is bringing the latest from the courtroom every day and will have full coverage of the trial here.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
opinion Tom Mulcair: Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's train wreck of a final act
In his latest column for CTVNews.ca, former NDP leader and political analyst Tom Mulcair puts a spotlight on the 'spectacular failure' of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's final act on the political stage.
B.C. mayor gets calls from across Canada about 'crazy' plan to recruit doctors
A British Columbia community's "out-of-the-box" plan to ease its family doctor shortage by hiring physicians as city employees is sparking interest from across Canada, says Colwood Mayor Doug Kobayashi.
'There’s no support': Domestic abuse survivor shares difficulties leaving her relationship
An Edmonton woman who tried to flee an abusive relationship ended up back where she started in part due to a lack of shelter space.
opinion King Charles' Christmas: Who's in and who's out this year?
Christmas 2024 is set to be a Christmas like no other for the Royal Family, says royal commentator Afua Hagan. King Charles III has initiated the most important and significant transformation of royal Christmas celebrations in decades.
Baseball Hall of Famer Rickey Henderson dead at 65, reports say
Rickey Henderson, a Baseball Hall of Famer and Major League Baseball’s all-time stolen bases leader, is dead at 65, according to multiple reports.
Arizona third-grader saves choking friend
An Arizona third-grader is being recognized by his local fire department after saving a friend from choking.
Germans mourn the 5 killed and 200 injured in the apparent attack on a Christmas market
Germans on Saturday mourned the victims of an apparent attack in which authorities say a doctor drove into a busy outdoor Christmas market, killing five people, injuring 200 others and shaking the public’s sense of security at what would otherwise be a time of joy.
Blake Lively accuses 'It Ends With Us' director Justin Baldoni of harassment and smear campaign
Blake Lively has accused her 'It Ends With Us' director and co-star Justin Baldoni of sexual harassment on the set of the movie and a subsequent effort to “destroy' her reputation in a legal complaint.
Oysters distributed in B.C., Alberta, Ontario recalled for norovirus contamination
The Canadian Food Inspection Agency has issued a recall due to possible norovirus contamination of certain oysters distributed in British Columbia, Alberta and Ontario.