Ontario's top court orders new hearing for youth-led climate case
Ontario's top court breathed new life into a Charter challenge of the provincial government's emissions target on Thursday, a decision heralded as a major victory for the group of young people -- including 17-year-old Sophia Mathur from Greater Sudbury -- who brought the case and others looking to hold governments to account on climate change.
The group of seven young people who brought the Mathur v. Ontario case in order to hold the Ontario government to account on climate change. (Tilly Nelson/EcoJustice)
The Ontario Court of Appeal's ruling sends the case back to the lower court for a new hearing and revives the possibility that Ontario's weakened emissions target may still be found unconstitutional.
"The issues raised on the application must be considered afresh and through the correct analytical lens," Thursday's decision said, while poking holes in the lower court judge's original ruling.
The Appeal Court stopped short of making its own decision on the target's constitutionality or ordering the province to instead replace it with a "science-based" target, as the group had sought.
The Mathur v. Ontario case, named after lead applicant from northern Ontario, is the first case to be tried in Canada that considers whether a government's climate-change approach has the potential to violate the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
‘They work for us’
Mathur says although she and other youth can't yet vote, politicians need to be reminded "that they work for us."
"I believe that our case can make a real difference for young people in Canada and put Ontario back on track to take real climate action and start working for a safer future," she said during a virtual news conference Thursday.
"Our win today shows that our voices and concerns matter."
Greater Sudbury teen climate activist Sophia Mathur speaks during a virtual press conference on October 17, 2024, following the Ontario Court of Appeal's ruling that a lower court must re-examine if Ontario's weakened emissions target has the potential to violate the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. (CTV News | Video source: EcoJustice)
The youth's case
At stake was an emissions target that Premier Doug Ford's then-newly elected Progressive Conservative government set after it repealed the law underpinning Ontario's cap-and-trade system for lowering emissions.
The government scrapped the system in 2018 and replaced the emissions target in that law -- 37 per cent below 1990 levels by 2030 -- with a new target of 30 per cent below 2005 levels.
The young people brought evidence to suggest the revised target would allow for 30 megatonnes more in annual emissions leading up to 2030, equivalent to the annual emissions of about seven million passenger vehicles or nearly 200 megatonnes from 2018 to 2030.
The lower court ruling
In a decision last year, an Ontario Superior Court justice agreed the gap between how much emissions need to be cut globally and what the provincial plan calls for is "large, unexplained and without any apparent scientific basis."
The court also found that Ontario was increasing the risk of death faced by young people -- citing how climate change fuels forest fires, floods and infectious disease spread, and has a disproportionate impact on Indigenous youth -- by not taking steps to further reduce its emissions.
The ruling noted that to align with international standards, Ontario would need a more stringent target that aims for emissions to be half of what they were in 2005 by 2030.
But the judge disagreed that the province's emissions target amounted to a Charter violation. It wasn't that the province's target increased emissions, but that it allegedly did not do enough to reduce them.
The lower court judge ruled in dismissing the challenge that the applicants were trying to impose a "freestanding" obligation on the province to fight climate change.
Province has volunteered to fight climate change, court rules
The Appeal Court disagreed. Ontario had voluntarily made a statutory commitment to combat climate change, Thursday's ruling said.
"The question is whether the application judge should have considered whether Ontario's alleged failure to comply with its statutory obligation violated the appellants' Charter rights," the decision read.
Provincial lawyers respond
In a written statement reacting to the decision, a spokesperson for Ontario's attorney general touted the province's investments in cleaner steel production and transit expansion.
"We are on track to meet emissions reduction targets and will continue to build on our success by ensuring Ontario remains a global leader," said Jack Fazzari, a press secretary for Attorney General Doug Downey.
The case is part of a wave of challenges in Canada and abroad asking courts to take a more active role in overseeing governments' climate plans.
The top court in the Netherlands ruled in 2019 that the Dutch government had a duty to protect citizens from the potentially devastating effects of climate change. It upheld lower court decisions that ordered the government to further cut emissions.
Case lays a ‘solid foundation’ for future victories, one expert says
Thursday's ruling in Ontario has laid a "solid foundation" for a potential victory in the new hearing, said Stepan Wood, a professor at the University of British Columbia.
"This unanimous decision is a major victory for Canadian children and youth who are seeking to hold governments accountable for their contributions to climate change," Wood, a Canada Research Chair in law, society and sustainability, said in a written reaction to the decision.
The Ontario Court of Appeal is seen in Toronto, Monday, April 8, 2019. (Colin Perkel/The Canadian Press)
Lawyers in another youth-led Charter challenge were watching closely, too. Their case, which challenges the federal government's overall climate plan, is currently before the Federal Court.
"Today's decision is very significant because it confirms that climate change is causing severe harms in Canada, and that the government can be held to account for its role in causing those harms," said Catherine Boies Parker, a lawyer for the applicants in that case.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Oct. 17, 2024.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Cuba's power grid fails, plunging country into darkness
Cuba's national electrical grid shut down on Friday after one of the island's major power plants failed, Cuba's energy ministry said, plunging the entire country into a blackout.
Arrests made after gunshots fired at Toronto Jewish girls' school
A 20-year-old man and a 17-year-old boy are facing multiple charges after allegedly firing gunshots at a Jewish girls' school last weekend.
SaskPower receives largest workplace fine in province's history for 2020 deaths of employees in Weyburn
SaskPower was sentenced Friday morning in a Weyburn courtroom, receiving a record fine, after being found guilty of three workplace-safety related violations when two experienced employees were killed on the job in 2020.
Suspect charged in hand-scooping incident at B.C. frozen yogurt shop
Days after a man was recorded walking behind the counter at a frozen yogurt shop in Richmond, B.C., and scooping product with his hand, a suspect has been criminally charged.
Thousands of hybrid vehicles recalled in Canada over risk of fire
An increased risk of fire has prompted the recall of thousands of Honda hybrid vehicles in Canada.
Cabinet minister who is quitting voices confidence in Trudeau
One of four Canadian cabinet members who are stepping down said on Friday that he has confidence in Liberal Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, and he played down polls predicting the Liberals will badly lose in the next election.
Dog spotted hanging out on top of ancient pyramid in Egypt
While flying over Egypt’s famous Great Pyramids at sunrise earlier this week, US paraglider Marshall Mosher and fellow paragliders spotted the unexpected sight of a stray hound also taking in views around the summit of one of the ancient wonders.
Trump compares jailed U.S. Capitol rioters to Japanese internment during Second World War
Former U.S. president Donald Trump on Friday compared the people jailed on charges that they stormed the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, to the more than 120,000 people of Japanese origin incarcerated on U.S. soil during World War II.
Woman arrested after allegedly throwing a cup of bodily fluids at Saskatoon bus passengers, breaking window
A 29-year-old Saskatoon woman faces assault and mischief charges after allegedly throwing a cup of bodily fluids on two bus passengers and breaking a window on Thursday.