Judge aims to issue a quick decision in case of northern Ont. homes contaminated with radioactive rock
A federal appeals hearing ended Thursday involving three homeowners from Elliot Lake, Ont., seeking to have radioactive rock removed from their homes.
Federal Court Justice Ann Marie McDonald heard the appeal in a Toronto courtroom over the last two days.
The homes were built in the 1950s and 1960s using rock waste taken from a nearby uranium mine, then owned by Rio Algom. The rock was used in crawl spaces and driveways in the homes and has since tested for dangerously high levels of radiation.
The homeowners appealed to the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission (CNSC) to inspect their homes and order the removal of the rock, using their authority under the Nuclear Safety and Control Act.
While the mine has since closed, the property is now owned by BHP, which would be responsible for any cleanup ordered by the CNSC.
However, the commission ruled that it doesn’t have the jurisdiction to make such an order because, under its definition, the rock used in the homes isn’t rock waste associated with the production of nuclear energy.
The homeowners are appealing that decision, aided by lawyers from the Canadian Environmental Law Association. The CNSC was represented by lawyers from the Attorney General of Canada.
Both sides agreed that the rock was waste rock taken from the mine after it was separated from uranium ore. They also agree that it contains high levels of radiation.
One property tested positive for radon with a level of 858.7 Bq/m³. To put that in perspective, Health Canada's guideline for radon exposure is only 200 Bq/m³. (Photo from video)
The disagreement centres on the definition of nuclear mine waste. Lawyer Jacqueline Wilson, representing the homeowners, argued that since the rock was mined and separated from the ore, it qualifies as waste rock under the legislation.
But lawyers defending the CNSC argued that the commission only has authority over mining waste that actually goes through the mining process, such as mine tailings.
In this case, the fact the rock is radioactive doesn’t matter.
'Natural radiation'
“These rocks already had some natural radiation,” said lawyer James Schneider.
“It’s not associated with the production of nuclear energy … Naturally occurring substances are not under the CNSC jurisdiction.”
To be under the control of the CNSC, Schneider argued that the rock had to be chemically treated in a mining process.
“It’s a question of what is natural and not natural,” he said.
Schneider was relying on Section 10 of the Act, which exempts material that is “naturally occurring nuclear substances, other than those that are or have been associated with the development, production or use of nuclear energy.”
But Justice McDonald said the matter wasn’t that simple.
“It doesn’t exempt it quite as clearly as you suggest,” she said.
“What’s sitting in the truck, whether it’s a nuclear substance, no one can answer that without looking into it.”
The nuclear cycle
But Schneider said the rock in the Elliot Lake homes “was never intended to enter the nuclear cycle.”
“It’s known as waste rock,” he said. “It had been broken up and moved, but never processed for the nuclear cycle.”
He also argued that the public has no formal right to force the CNSC to do an inspection.
Comparing it to the police’s right to decide whether to investigate a complaint, he said the commission has the power to do an inspection “but there is no obligation here.”
Lawyer Margaret Cormack, also defending the CNSC, said the case largely centred on whether the commission’s decision not to investigate was unreasonable.
There is a high bar for ruling a decision is unreasonable, Cormack said. In this case, she said the issue is whether the rock was used in the production of nuclear energy.
And that only happens through a chemical process that the rocks in question never went through. They were only transported a short distance away to be used in the homes.
“This is the totality of what happened to these rocks,” Cormack said.
“These are not rocks that were going to be processed for nuclear fission or transmutation … It’s on that basis that the CNSC is making its decision.”
In her reply, Wilson argued that nowhere in the legislation does it say the rocks have to go through a chemical process to be considered nuclear waste.
“This is not an argument that has ever been made in interpreting Section 10,” she said.
Wilson argued that they were trying to rewrite the legislation by adding the “chemically processed” provision, but the Act itself doesn’t contain those words.
In fact, she said, “waste rock is never chemically processed.”
- Download our app to get local alerts on your device
- Get the latest local updates right to your inbox
If you examine the language of the Act, Wilson said it’s clear that it regulates mineralized waste rock because of its potential to cause harm to human health, as is the case in the Elliot Lake homes.
“There’s a real danger here,” she said. “There’s a real concern.”
McDonald reserved her decision in the case, saying she hoped to issue a written decision soon.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.6954495.1720351790!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
Vehicle supply building. Prices are going down. Is it time to buy a new car?
For the first time in years, car shoppers are having an easier time finding a deal as the auto industry bounces back from supply chain woes — and experts say the outlook could get even better.
Torrid heat bakes millions of people in large swaths of U.S., setting records and fanning wildfires
Roughly 130 million people were under threat over the weekend and into next week from a long-running heat wave that broke or tied records with dangerously high temperatures and is expected to shatter more from East Coast to West Coast, forecasters said.
Jon Landau, Oscar-winning 'Titanic' and 'Avatar' producer, dies at 63
Jon Landau, an Oscar-winning producer who worked closely with director James Cameron on three of the biggest blockbusters of all time, 'Titanic' and two 'Avatar' films, has died. He was 63.
This Italian vacation hotspot is turning tourists away as it runs out of water
Set atop a hill on the Italian island of Sicily, Agrigento is a heritage tourist’s paradise. But the aqueduct, and others built in modern times, are running so dry that small hotels and guesthouses in the city and nearby coast are being forced to turn tourists away.
Japan’s tourism tax sparks industry speculation in Canada
Japan has introduced a tourism tax for Mount Fuji, which has prompted some in Canada to wonder if our own tourist destinations like Niagara Falls and the Bay of Fundy could be potential options for our own tourism tax.
Crew of NASA's earthbound simulated Mars habitat emerge after a year
The crew of a NASA mission to Mars emerged from their craft after a yearlong voyage that never left Earth.
Terrorism charges laid against B.C. woman who married ISIS fighter
A B.C. woman who was repatriated from a Syrian prison camp in 2022 has been arrested and charged with terrorism offences, police announced Saturday.
How to lower your student debt -- and cut through misconceptions around it
Paying back student loans has always been a challenge, but at a time when housing and meals eat up a bigger slice of income than ever, making smart choices around loans and repayment is all too critical.
4 in 10 Canadians say theft is a risk factor in vehicle purchasing: Nanos
As many as four out of 10 Canadians say it is 'important' to know if a vehicle they're interested in purchasing is more likely to be targeted by thieves, according to a new Nanos Research survey.