Triple murder suspect in Sudbury admits to manslaughter, denies murder
A triple murder suspect in Sudbury admits he is guilty of manslaughter, but denies he meant to kill anyone in a fatal arson three years ago.
Liam Stinson is also charged with arson causing bodily harm, another charge he admits. The Crown and defence made their closing arguments Wednesday in Sudbury court after a trial that has lasted more than six weeks.
Jamie-Lynn Rose, Jasmine Somers and Guy Henri died following a fire at a townhouse on Bruce Avenue on April 11, 2021. One other person, David Cheff, was seriously injured.
Crown prosecutors had previously said they plan to prove that Stinson offered drugs to get two men to agree to firebomb the townhouse. It belonged to Cheff, who had been helping Stinson’s estranged girlfriend, Jamie-Lynn Rose.
Two men admitted to setting the fire using Molotov cocktails fashioned from empty Gatorade bottles. Both testified that Stinson agreed to give them fentanyl in exchange for setting the fire.
In her closing remarks, assistant Crown attorney Kaely Whillans said the evidence showed Stinson planned the fire, knew the victims would be home, high on drugs and asleep.
Considering the fire started at 4:40 a.m., Whillans said Stinson knew they would have no way of escaping.
“The residents were as vulnerable to fire as anyone could be,” she said.
They were high and cut off from the exits and Stinson “knew all of these things.”
Describing it as a “planned and deliberate murder,” Whillans said he wanted the victims severely injured or dead.
Text messages show Stinson was upset that Rose had ended their “toxic” relationship, she said. She had tried several times to leave in the previous months, but was manipulated by Stinson to return, Whillans said.
Three people died in the April 11, 2021, arson: Jasmine Marie-Claire Somers, left, Jamie-Lynn Lori-Lee Rose and Guy Armand Henri. (File)
Rose had finally left for good and moved into Cheff’s place, something that Stinson couldn’t stand. She had stolen drugs from Stinson, wouldn’t respond to his messages and was staying at another man’s residence.
So he tricked the two men into thinking nobody would be home and offered them drugs if they threw Molotov cocktails inside late at night.
Why would he use two Molotov cocktails if he just wanted to send a message? Whillans asked.
“It was meant to burn down a house, knowing there would people inside.”
“He is responsible for the death and bodily harm the residents suffered as a result,” Whillans added.
“You are to decide what he wanted to occur ... I suggest to you there is nothing else he could have wanted but their deaths.”
In his remarks, defence lawyer Joseph Wilkinson said the evidence shows his client is guilty of manslaughter – but not first- or second-degree murder.
“Just because he lived a lifestyle you may deplore, you must not reason that he is less worthy of protection from the law,” Wilkinson said.
Make a decision without bias
“You must judge the evidence in this case without bias.”
He laid out several reasons to acquit Stinson on murder charges. First, he said Stinson had no motive. While they had a bad relationship, Rose and Stinson exchanged texts not long before the fire that showed no animosity.
“Mr. Stinson had no reason to want (the victims) dead,” Wilkinson said, adding he didn’t even know one of them.
And there’s evidence that Rose willingly returned to Stinson’s place many times “completely voluntarily.”
While she had stolen drugs from him, it was not the first time and there was no evidence Stinson was particularly angry.
“The communications do not suggest Mr. Stinson was upset about the gram (of drugs).” He said.
'Makes no sense'
“The Crown’s theory makes no sense.”
He also argued that Stinson was so intoxicated that night, he couldn’t form the intent to kill anyone. He had been smoking crack cocaine and drinking all evening.
“Evidence of intoxication should raise serious doubt,” Wilkinson said.
He also argued that Stinson thought no one was home, because Rose had talked about going to Timmins. Stinson even offered to pay for her ticket in one text exchange. And Cheff had told him he was going to Timmins that weekend to see his kids – plans he later cancelled.
A more likely scenario, Wilkinson said, was that Stinson was wasted and asked the two men to set the fire without contemplating the consequences or having a motive, Wilkinson said.
- Download our app to get local alerts on your device
- Get the latest local updates right to your inbox
“Mr. Stinson made a stupid mistake” but did not intend to kill anyone, he said.
“You should find Mr. Stinson not guilty (of murder).”
The jury will receive their instructions from the judge Thursday morning before beginning deliberations on a verdict.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Serial sexual offender linked to unsolved 1970s homicides of four Calgary girls, women
An investigation into unsolved historical homicides from the 1970s has linked the deaths of two girls and two young women in and around Calgary to a now-deceased serial offender.
Woman with liver failure rejected for a transplant after medical review highlights alcohol use
For nearly three months, Amanda Huska has been in an Ontario hospital, part of it on life support, because of severe liver failure. Her history of alcohol use is getting in the way of her only potential treatment: a liver transplant.
Video appears to show Sean 'Diddy' Combs beating singer Cassie in hotel hallway in 2016
Security video aired by CNN appears to show Sean 'Diddy' Combs physically assaulting singer Cassie in a Los Angeles hotel hallway in 2016.
Scottie Scheffler isn't the first pro golfer to be arrested during a tournament
Scottie Scheffler's arrest hours before his second-round tee time at the PGA Championship in Louisville, Kentucky, will go down as one of the most shocking in professional golf history. It certainly wasn't the first, though.
B.C. man 'attacked suddenly' by adult grizzly near Alberta border: RCMP
A B.C. man is recovering from multiple injuries after he was "attacked suddenly" by an adult grizzly bear near Elkford Thursday afternoon.
Anglers reel in 3.5-metre-long tiger shark off coast of Florida: 'She found my bait'
A group of fishers said it took roughly 20 minutes to reel in this 3.5-metre-long tiger shark off the coast of Florida.
Australia's richest woman seeks removal of her portrait from exhibition
Art is subjective. And while many artists long to share their work with the world, there's no guarantee that the audience will understand it, or even like it.
Canadian convicted of attacking Nancy Pelosi's husband with a hammer sentenced to 30 years
The man convicted of attempting to kidnap then-U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and attacking her husband with a hammer was sentenced Friday to 30 years in prison.
NEW What a wildfire survivor says she regrets not grabbing before leaving home
Carol Christian had 15 minutes to evacuate her home during the Fort McMurray wildfires in 2016. She ended up losing the house and everything inside. Now, she wants to share the lessons she learned.