Thorneloe University loses fight to reverse termination of its relationship with Laurentian University
The Court of Appeal for Ontario has rejected an attempt by Thorneloe University to reverse the decision by Laurentian University to terminate its relationship.
As part of its insolvency process, LU ended the federated university agreement it has had with Thorneloe, the University of Sudbury and Huntington University since the 1960s. Huntington reached a separation agreement with Laurentian, while the U of S and Thorneloe appealed to the courts, which sided with Laurentian.
Thorneloe appealed that ruling, and in a decision dated June 23, the appeals court sided with Laurentian.
"At the heart of its submissions is its contention that allowing the disclaimer will result in Thorneloe’s insolvency and yet provide only de minimis (minimal) financial benefit to Laurentian, and that the motive for the disclaimer is the elimination of competition, which is inconsistent with the duty to act in good faith," the three appeals judges wrote in their decision.
But under the Companies' Creditor Arrangement Act (CCAA), through which LU declared insolvency, when an agreement is disclaimed, courts must strike a balance between considering the harm to institutions like Thorneloe with the need for the insolvency process to succeed.
When there are no win-win decisions in cases like this, courts must make "the least undesirable choice."
The judge hearing the CCAA case said terminating the agreements with the three federated universities would result in an additional $7.7 million in increased revenue for LU. And that agreeing to maintain the agreement with Thorneloe would mean Huntington would receive the same treatment.
Under its deal with LU, "if Thorneloe or U Sudbury are permitted to continue to receive funding from Laurentian to teach courses or programs, Huntington will be similarly entitled," the transcript of the decision said.
'If Laurentian collapses, Thorneloe will collapse'
And terminating the agreement was also required by the DIP lender – the term for the group forwarding Laurentian loans for operations until the insolvency process is concluded.
Restoring Thorneloe's agreement with LU would have the effect of endangering the university's attempt to restructure, the court ruled.
"The CCAA judge found that if Laurentian collapses, Thorneloe will collapse," the transcript said.
"Thorneloe could only be an ongoing solvent entity if Laurentian could successfully restructure while keeping the agreements with Thorneloe in place. But that option was not available, as the CCAA judge accepted the monitor’s view that the disclaimer of the agreements was necessary for a viable restructuring of Laurentian to occur."
So in this case, the least undesirable decision is to allow the termination of the agreements to stand, the justices ruled.
"While we recognize the serious financial implications of the disclaimer for Thorneloe, we are simply not persuaded that there is an arguable basis for interfering with the CCAA judge’s factual findings or legal conclusions."
Read the full decision here.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Mystik Dan wins the 150th Kentucky Derby at Churchill Downs in a three-horse photo finish
Mystik Dan won the 150th Kentucky Derby in a photo finish, edging out Forever Young and Sierra Leone for the upset victory.
Bodies recovered in Mexico likely 2 Australians, 1 American who went missing: officials
Three bodies recovered in an area of Baja California are likely to be those of the two Australians and an American who went missing last weekend during a camping and surfing trip, the state prosecutor’s office said Saturday.
No proof man lied to brother about number of kittens born in litter, B.C. tribunal rules
A man was denied a $5,000 payout from his brother after a B.C. tribunal dismissed his claim disputing how many kittens were born in a litter.
Work stoppage possible as WestJet issues lockout notice to maintenance engineers' union
A lockout notice issued by WestJet to a union representing aircraft maintenance engineers could result in a work stoppage next week.
'I just can't believe that it took so long': Body found in wreckage 3 months after deadly fire
A man accused of arson in a January Old Strathcona apartment fire is expected to be charged with manslaughter after a body was discovered in the burned building late last month.
Quebec police hand out hundreds of tickets to Hells Angels and other bikers before 'first run' meeting
Quebec provincial police handed out hundreds of fines to Hells Angels members and other supporting motorcycle clubs who met for their 'first run' in a small town near Sherbrooke, Que.
Princess Anne lays wreath at B.C. veteran's cemetery; receives 21-gun salute
Princess Anne paid tribute to veterans buried at a cemetery in British Columbia today, laying a wreath to honour the more than 2,500 military personnel and family members buried there.
London Drugs begins 'gradual reopening' on 7th day after cyberattack
Almost a week after all London Drugs stores across Western Canada abruptly closed amid a cyberattack, they began a "gradual reopening" on Saturday.
Russia puts Ukrainian President Zelenskyy on its wanted list
Russia has put Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy on its wanted list, Russian state media reported Saturday, citing the interior ministry’s database.