Ontario's auditor general doesn't have the power to demand privileged documents, court rules
A court has ruled that Ontario's Auditor General Act does not give the auditor the power to demand access to documents covered by lawyer-client privilege.
Since last summer, Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk has been embroiled in a dispute with Laurentian University over access to privileged information as she conducts a value-for-money audit of the insolvent institution.
Lysyk went to court to argue that wording in the legislation compelled audit subjects to hand over all documents, and allow her to interview anyone she wants, including LU's former lawyer.
Laurentian responded by saying the act gives them the option to hand over the documents, but doesn't compel them.
While a victory for the university, the same court has yet to rule on a Speaker's warrant issued by the Ontario legislature demanding LU hand over all the information Lysyk is seeking.
But in the decision released Tuesday, Superior Court Chief Justice G.B. Morawetz ruled that, while legislation can compel audit subjects to hand over privileged information, the legislation has to be clear and unambiguous.
Morawetz wrote that past court rulings have said lawyer-client privilege is one of the pillars of the Canadian justice system.
"Further, to remain effective, it 'must remain as close to absolute as possible and should not be interfered with unless absolutely necessary,'" he wrote in his decision.
While the act has language that covers how the auditor general must handle privileged documents, it doesn't explicitly give her the power to demand the information.
"The question for determination is whether … the act demonstrates a clear, explicit, and unambiguous intention to abrogate solicitor-client privilege, litigation privilege, and settlement privilege," Morawetz wrote.
"To state the obvious, the legislature could have adopted the route followed by the province of Nova Scotia and enacted legislation that clearly expressed an unambiguous intention to abrogate solicitor-client privilege. It did not do so."
The way the language in the act is written covers how lawyer-client information should be handled, the judge said, but does not discuss the power of the auditor general to demand that information.
To accept arguments from the auditor general's office "requires reading into the statute something that is not expressly stated," Morawetz said.
While dismissing the motion, the judge said he wasn't ruling on Laurentian's arguments that a law requiring them to hand over the information would violate Canada's constitution.
"It is not necessary for me to address this issue," Morawetz said, adding that Laurentian had not taken the required steps for a ruling on a constitutional issue.
In a statement, Laurentian welcomed the decision.
"We will continue to provide the auditor general with the documentation and non-privileged information she needs, and is entitled to receive, in order to perform her audit," the release said.
The school also refuted suggestions by Lysyk that it had created "a culture of fear" when it comes to dealing with the audit.
"Laurentian has authorized and encouraged all staff to participate in interviews with the Auditor General of Ontario, provided no privileged information is relayed," the school said.
"We have also granted her office direct access to our entire financial database, enrollment system, as well as a substantial volume of other non-privileged documentation covering many decades."
For her part, Lysyk told CTV News she plans to appeal the decision, adding she's disappointed Laurentian has chosen to go to court to fight her attempts to complete her audit. She's concerned the way Laurentian is providing information is making it unclear whether non-privileged information is also being withheld.
Specifically, she said Laurentian is denying her full access to 2.4 million emails because some of them may contain privileged information, and offered to search the emails using search terms Lysyk provides.
That's unacceptable, she said, because organizations being audited aren't allowed to pick and choose what information they provide -- they are supposed to provide all information the auditor requires to complete her work.
In addition to siding with LU, Morawetz also awarded the university $25,000 in legal costs. Read the full decision here.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING Honda to get up to $5B in govt help for EV battery, assembly plants
Honda is set to build an electric vehicle battery plant next to its Alliston, Ont., assembly plant, which it is retooling to produce fully electric vehicles, all part of a $15-billion project that is expected to include up to $5 billion in public money.
BREAKING New York appeals court overturns Harvey Weinstein's 2020 rape conviction from landmark #MeToo trial
New York’s highest court on Thursday overturned Harvey Weinstein’s 2020 rape conviction, finding the judge at the landmark #MeToo trial prejudiced the ex-movie mogul with improper rulings, including a decision to let women testify about allegations that weren’t part of the case.
Residents of northern Alberta First Nation told to shelter in place
Residents of John D'Or Prairie, a community on the Little Red River Cree Nation in northern Alberta, were told to take shelter Thursday morning during a police operation.
Secret $70M Lotto Max winners break their silence
During a special winner celebration near their hometown, Doug and Enid shared the story of how they discovered they were holding a Lotto Max ticket worth $70 million and how they kept this huge secret for so long.
Remains from a mother-daughter cold case were found nearly 24 years later, after a deathbed confession from the suspect
A West Virginia father is getting some sense of closure after authorities found the remains of his young daughter and her mother following a deathbed confession from the man believed to have fatally shot them nearly two decades ago.
Monthly earnings rise, payroll employment falls: jobs report
The number of vacant jobs in Canada increased in February, while monthly payroll employment decreased in food services, manufacturing, and retail trade, among other sectors.
First in Canada procedure performed at London, Ont. hospital
A London man has become the first person in Canada to receive a robotic assisted surgery on his spine. Dave Myeh suffered from debilitating, chronic back pain that led to sciatica in his right now and extreme pain in his lower back.
Doctors say capital gains tax changes will jeopardize their retirement. Is that true?
The Canadian Medical Association asserts the Liberals' proposed changes to capital gains taxation will put doctors' retirement savings in jeopardy, but some financial experts insist incorporated professionals are not as doomed as they say they are.
Something in the water? Canadian family latest to spot elusive 'Loch Ness Monster'
For centuries, people have wondered what, if anything, might be lurking beneath the surface of Loch Ness in Scotland. When Canadian couple Parry Malm and Shannon Wiseman visited the Scottish highlands earlier this month with their two children, they didn’t expect to become part of the mystery.