North Bay, Ont., woman was discriminated against when she was fired, tribunal rules
The manager of a Tim Hortons in North Bay was wrong to fire a long-term employee because of her physical limitations, the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario has ruled.
The tribunal awarded the woman more than $35,000, including $20,000 for “injury to her dignity, feelings and self-respect.”
The woman was 61 when she was let go in November 2017. She had worked at the restaurant for 18 years. She appealed to the tribunal, alleging “discrimination because of disability and/or age contrary to the Human Rights Code,” according to the transcript of the proceeding.
In response, the employer argued that her physical limitations had gotten to the point she could no longer perform basic duties. Under the law, employers are required to accommodate people with disabilities only “up to the point of undue hardship.”
The tribunal hearing was held in August 2022 and the decision was released earlier this month.
Problems began when the woman developed serious shoulder and knee pain in 2016.
“These medical conditions … were causing her physical limitations at work,” the transcript said.
As a frontline employee, the woman’s tasks included working in the drive-thru, front counter, making soup and sandwiches, cleaning, sweeping, restocking items and checking washrooms.
“The parties agree that during her employment, the applicant reported to the respondent that she had some medical concerns that restricted her from performing some of the tasks,” the transcript said.
“The respondent provided accommodations to the applicant based on these reported medical concerns, by permitting her to withdraw from particular tasks.”
In addition to physical limitations, the woman could no longer prepare sandwiches because she was allergic to the gloves employees had to wear while making them.
“The applicant was removed from stocking duties that required climbing a ladder after she reported in 2016 that climbing the top portion of the ladder caused her vertigo,” the transcript said.
“The applicant was removed from sweeping and mopping duties after she reported that it caused her shoulder pain. At some point, the respondent also withdrew the applicant from drive-thru and coffee/beverage duties. The parties now dispute whether she could perform these duties.”
As a result, her duties were limited to greeting customers, working the front counter cash, “finalizing transactions, some stocking, some cleaning, bathroom checks and filling fridges.”
She told her supervisor she could no longer fill fridges because it caused her shoulder pain. At that point, her employer told her she needed a doctor’s note.
The note, dated Nov. 2, 2017, stated: “This patient has limitations in bending, twisting, of shoulders, neck and knees. She cannot kneel or bend to reach and lift items that are below the waist. She can work at waist level. She cannot lift above her head. She may require breaks and to work at her own pace.”
When she showed it to her manager the next day, she was terminated.
“The general manager acknowledged receipt of the doctor’s notes,” the transcript said.
“He testified that in his judgment, she could not do the job anymore because there were not enough tasks that she could do to fill the day. He testified that she could not serve coffee and could not work in the drive-thru, which he says were essential tasks.”
However, the tribunal ruled that the fact she was dismissed the same day she showed them the doctor’s note was “highly relevant” to the woman’s case.
'ACCOMMODATION DIALOGUE'
That’s because under Ontario law, employers are required to have “accommodation dialogue” with employees with physical limitations.
“The respondent did not request information about the applicant’s prognosis, whether her medical needs and restrictions were permanent in nature as they related to her ability to perform her work duties, and/or the anticipated duration of her medical needs and restrictions,” the transcript said.
“The respondent did not provide the applicant’s physician with a description of the essential duties of the applicant’s job to request her further input on what accommodation could be provided to allow the applicant to perform those duties. The applicant’s physician testified that she would normally expect to receive a form from an employer to assist her with requests for workplace accommodation.”
If the employer had made those inquiries, the tribunal said it could have assessed whether the limitations were permanent and whether there were duties she could perform in the interim.
The woman had knee replacement surgery in 2018 and shoulder surgery in 2019.
“With further information that was available at that time, the parties would have been able to give consideration to what reasonable accommodation could have been provided to the applicant, perhaps on a temporary basis, within the factual matrix before them,” the tribunal said.
Letting her go the same day they received the doctor’s note is evidence that the employer “failed to consider what accommodation options there were.”
In other words, the employer had to assess whether there were solutions available to accommodate the employee “up to the point of undue hardship” before making a decision to terminate their employment.
The woman sought $25,000 “for injury to dignity, feelings and self-respect,” and the tribunal awarded $20,000. She was also awarded $15,290.40 in lost wages, covering from the day she was fired until the day she had knee replacement surgery.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Most of Canada to receive emergency alert test today
The federal government will test its capacity to issue emergency alerts today, with the exception of Ontario, where the test will take place on May 15.
'A huge difference': These adults born in the '90s partnered with their parents to buy homes in Ontario
An Ontario woman said it would have been impossible to buy a house without her mother – an anecdote that animates the fact that over 17 per cent of Canadian homeowners born in the ‘90s own their property with their parents, according to a new report.
OPINION No reunion between Prince Harry and the King signifies a setback for royal unity
Prince Harry, the Duke of Sussex, has made headlines with his recent arrival in the U.K., this time to celebrate all things Invictus. But upon the prince landing in the U.K., we have already had confirmation that King Charles III won't have time to see his youngest son during his brief visit.
Northern Ont. woman makes 'eggstraordinary' find
A chicken farmer near Mattawa made an 'eggstraordinary' find Friday morning when she discovered one of her hens laid an egg close to three times the size of an average large chicken egg.
How Drake and Kendrick Lamar's rap beef escalated within weeks
A long-simmering feud between hip-hop superstars Drake and Kendrick Lamar reached a boiling point in recent days as the pair traded increasingly personal insults on a succession of diss tracks. Here’s a quick overview of what’s behind the ongoing beef.
NEW For their protection, immigrants critical of China and India call for speedy passage of Canada's foreign interference legislation
Canadian immigrants threatened by hostile regimes are urging parliamentarians to quickly pass the 'Countering Foreign Interference Act' so they can feel safe living in their adopted home.
Ontario man devastated to learn $150,000 line of credit isn't insured after wife dies
An Ontario man found out that a line of credit he thought was insured actually isn't after his wife of 50 years died.
Spanish prosecutors recommend 2nd investigation into Shakira's taxes be thrown out
Spanish state prosecutors recommended Wednesday that an investigating judge shelve a probe into another alleged case of tax fraud by pop star Shakira.
Stormy Daniels describes meeting Trump during occasionally graphic testimony in hush money trial
With Donald Trump sitting just feet away, Stormy Daniels testified Tuesday at the former president's hush money trial about a sexual encounter the porn actor says they had in 2006 that resulted in her being paid to keep silent during the presidential race 10 years later.