Skip to main content

Nipissing First Nation members protest plan to distribute Robinson Huron treaty funds


A vote in April will decide how much money from the Robinson Huron Treaty settlement will remain with the Nipissing First Nation and how much will be distributed to members.

But not everyone is happy with the plan. A group of about 40 First Nations people demonstrated outside of the band office on Semo Road on Monday, expressing their concerns about how the First Nation is distributing the money.

Frustrated with their chief and council, the protesters said they are upset about what they call a lack of “transparency and accountability.”

“How can they sign a settlement agreement without any of the members not knowing anything about it?” said demonstrator Jan Couchie.

The protestors worry the money won’t be fairly or evenly distributed.

“When it pertains to anything treaty rights, the membership has the right to know,” Couchie said.

“We have it in our constitution on our NFN that we are to be notified and we were not notified.”

A group of about 40 First Nations people demonstrated outside of the band office on Semo Road on Monday, expressing their concerns about how the First Nation is distributing money from the settlement. (Eric Taschner/CTV News)

Each First Nation has the option to disperse its share of the settlement however it sees fit.

“We didn’t have that option,” Couchie said. “That option was taken away from.”

She was referring to a Nipissing First Nation council decision to take money from the cheques of each First Nations member to support what the group describes as a community “legacy project.”

A vote is coming up in a few weeks to determine how much money is going to go to members and how much will be used for the project. There are two choices currently on the ballot: 25 per cent will stay with the First Nation or 35 per cent.

'Doesn't seem fair'

“That doesn’t seem fair to me. We don’t even know 25 per cent of what,” Couchie said.

The group is calling on council and Chief Scott McLeod to reconsider by adding a third voting option where each individual can choose how much they want to put in the pot, if any at all.

For his part, McLeod said the argument that individuals are giving up money is backward. That argument was made in court.

“It’s not all individual money. We signed the treaty as a nation,” McLeod said.

“There are no individual signatures. It’s the nation’s money going to the individual.”

Last June, the federal and provincial governments reached a historic $10 billion settlement with the Robinson Huron Treaty Litigation Fund, representing the 21 Robinson Huron First Nations.

The proposed settlement is to resolve claims related to past annuities, compensation that should have been paid for the past 170 years since the treaty was signed in 1850.

The settlement includes $5 billion from Canada and $5 billion from Ontario to be paid to all 21 First Nations included in the Treaty.

The amount each First Nation will receive has not yet been determined.

“We have to uphold the spirit and the intent of the treaty,” McLeod said.

Couchie said she expects most people will choose the lower option during the voting process. Top Stories


opinion The big benefits of adopting a debt-free lifestyle

In his column for, columnist Christopher Liew explains the benefits of adopting a debt-free lifestyle, as well as the change in financial mindset and sacrifices it takes.

They met in New York's Plaza Hotel in 1970. Here's what happened next

In 1969, Stefano Ripamonti was feeling good about life. He was in his late twenties, working a glamorous job at an Italian high fashion shoe firm. He’d recently married his childhood sweetheart and the newlyweds were settling into an apartment near the Vatican city walls in Rome, Italy.

Stay Connected