North Bay decorator still in court battle over COVID-19 pandemic restraining order
A North Bay decorator who made headlines during the COVID-19 pandemic is still involved in court battles related to her refusal to follow orders from the local health unit.
After repeated warnings from the North Bay Parry Sound District Health Unit, Alexandra Stewart was ordered to close her business to all but online sales in a motion dated April 17, 2021.
Stewart repeatedly refused to enforce COVID-related restrictions requiring customers to wear masks and enforce physical distance requirements.
A restraining order was granted May 21 of that year to enforce the health unit’s orders. Less than a month later, on June 11, the order was lifted as the province eased pandemic rules.
That didn’t end the court battle, however, as Stewart made an application to be compensated for “damages for economic injury allegedly sustained” by her business, Stewart’s Decorating, and related court costs. Both Stewart and her corporation were listed on the application.
In an unusual move, her lawyer applied to the Superior Court of Justice for permission to cross-examine health unit officials about the order without first providing any evidence or information explaining the arguments her lawyer planned to make on her behalf.
The reason? Stewart is still facing Provincial Offences Act cases related to her refusal to follow pandemic directives. She argued that delivering evidence in support of her application would violate her right to silence in the POA cases.
“Her refusal to depose her evidence at this time is explained in her desire to protect her right to silence,” the court decision said.
“Not guarding her right to silence, the argument continues, could result in non-compensable prejudice to both respondents.”
BREACH OF FAIRNESS
In response, the health unit argued that allowing their staff to be cross-examined without any information about the arguments Stewart’s lawyer planned to make would be a fundamental breach of fairness.
In its decision, the court ruled that Stewart may have the right to silence in her POA case, but the rules still require that evidence be produced for the current case before the courts unless there’s a reasonable argument to the contrary.
“In the context of these circumstances, I find that the right to silence protecting Ms. Stewart … does not outweigh the prejudice that would be suffered by the (health unit),” the court said.
- Download our app to get local alerts on your device
- Get the latest local updates right to your inbox
If Stewart’s lawyers are truly concerned about being prejudiced in the POA case, the court said it should wait until the POA case is completed before proceeding with the current application.
“The fact remains that, for all of the above reasons, hanging their hat on the right to silence would split the case, and is clearly a tactical strategy, which does not constitute a reasonable or adequate explanation,” the court said.
Read the full decision here.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
NEW Is there a cost to convenience? Canada approves new cancer immunotherapy treatment
A new cancer treatment recently approved in Canada promises to cut treatment time down to just minutes, but experts have differing opinions on whether it's what's best for patients.
Air Canada walks back new seat selection policy change after backlash
Air Canada has paused a new seat selection fee for travellers booked on the lowest fares just days after implementing it.
Canada's new dental program offering hope of free care to millions but many dentists aren't signed up
A new Canadian dental care program is offering the hope of free care to millions, but while 1.7 million people have signed up for the plan, only about 5,000 dentists have done the same.
Province boots mayor and council in small northern Ont. town out of office
An ongoing municipal strike, court battles and revolt by half of council has prompted the province to oust the mayor and council in Black River-Matheson.
'Fatalities' reported following wrong-way collision on Highway 401, SIU called in: police
Ontario's Special Investigations Unit has been called in following a deadly wrong-way collision on Highway 401 in Whitby on Monday night, say police.
Winner of US$1.3 billion Powerball jackpot is an immigrant from Laos who has cancer
One of the winners of a historic US$1.3 billion Powerball jackpot last month is an immigrant from Laos who has had cancer for eight years and had his latest chemotherapy treatment last week.
King Charles III returns to public duties with a trip to a cancer charity
King Charles III returned to public duties on Tuesday, visiting a cancer treatment charity and beginning his carefully managed comeback after the monarch's own cancer diagnosis sidelined him for three months.
NDP says Ottawa's new grocery task force isn't living up to government promises
The federal government says the task force it created to monitor and investigate grocery retailers' practices has not conducted any probes and doesn't have a mandate to take enforcement action.
A group of Toronto tenants have been on a rent strike for a year and say there's no resolution in sight
Dozens of tenants in Toronto's Thorncliffe Park area have now been withholding their rent for one year, and it’s unclear when the dispute will end.