Lawyers trade accusations in key hearing in battle between Laurentian, auditor general
Lawyers for Laurentian University and the auditor general battled it out in court Tuesday, presenting vastly differing versions of how both sides ended up there.
At issue is whether the Ontario legislature has the power to force Laurentian to hand over documents covered by lawyer-client privilege.
A court ruling last week said Ontario's Auditor General Act does not give Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk the right to access the confidential documents directly. She has said she will appeal.
Tuesday's hearing was to deal with a Speaker's warrant issued by the legislature before Christmas. It orders the insolvent university to hand over any and all documents Lysyk deems necessary to complete her value-for-money audit.
According to Laurentian's legal team, Lysyk is trying to do an "end run" around the law by having the legislature demand documents she is not entitled to access.
Lawyer Brian Gover told Superior Court Chief Justice Geoffrey B. Morawetz that LU tried to end the impasse by agreeing to hand over any document the auditor wants up until March 2020, 10 months before the school declared bankruptcy.
Gover said Lysyk's mandate is to audit the university's books, not to examine events after LU declared insolvency under the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act. Those documents include details of mediation between creditors and other parties, Gover said, which were undertaken with the assumption they would be confidential.
It amounts to an "end run around a statue that governs (the auditor's) operation," he said. "And that's not permitted … What would be wrong with the auditor general only having access that the legislation permits her to have?"
It's clear, he said, the legislature is trying to get the documents on behalf of Lysyk by using Parliamentary privilege -- an abuse of that privilege, he said.
"It is too much to ask the legislature to comply with its own laws?" Gover asked.
Frederick Shumann, another lawyer for Laurentian, said the Speaker's warrant is a "vast overreach of Parliamentary privilege" aimed at scaring future audit subjects into complying. Laurentian is willing to hand over all documents that don't deal with the CCAA proceedings, he added.
Shumann also said the case has become political, with MPPs eager to look good to Ontarians angry about the insolvency. But in doing so they haven't considered the implications of the legal precedent they are trying to establish.
"So this is not entirely about Laurentian," he said.
Demanding privileged documents is contrary to the law, he argued, as is issuing a Speaker's warrant when there is a court order in place requiring those documents remain confidential.
"We don't put individual rights at risk because of political considerations," Shumann said. "There is a constitutional line the committee cannot cross."
But David Taylor, lawyer for the Speaker, said Laurentian wants the court to determine the motive of the Ontario legislature – to help the auditor – rather than rule on the scope of Parliamentary privilege.
But the legislative assembly has the autonomy to make these requests in Canadian law, Taylor said, to ensure they have the information they need to make legislative and other decisions.
Courts should not be drawn into value judgments that are under the control of the legislature, he argued.
"It's a vital necessity to fulfill its constitutional role," Taylor said. "It's up to the assembly to decide which information it requires."
Morawetz asked whether the effect of the Speaker's warrant is to make the court decision on the Auditor General's Act moot.
"Is that not doing an end run around a decision that was delivered recently?" he asked.
Taylor replied that the act limits what documents Lysyk can demand, but doesn't put limits on what the legislature can request.
"In light of limitations (of the act), public accounts committee seeks to provide a more complete record upon which she can conduct her value-for-money audit," he said.
Morawetz said he was struggling with the idea that parties who entered into agreements they believed to be confidential would now have to give up that privacy. Further, he couldn't see why the post CCAA- filing documents are necessary for the audit.
"That's what I'm really struggling with," he said.
Taylor responded that handing over the documents wouldn't be surrendering confidentiality, since both the legislature and the auditor have to keep them confidential.
"And later documents may shed light on preceding events" before insolvency was declared, he added.
Josh Hunter, lawyer for the Attorney General, said the court should hesitate before limiting the power of Parliamentary privilege.
"We are talking about limiting a power granted to the assembly by the constitution," Hunter said. "Parliament gave Laurentian the right to keep information confidential from its creditors, but not the legislative assembly."
Instead of continuing its court fight, LU should just cooperate with Lysyk, he added.
"After all, what does it have to hide?"
Morawetz said it was a complicated case, but he was aware time was a factor.
"I will endeavour to render a decision as soon as possible," he said.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
'They needed people inside Air Canada:' Police announce arrests in Pearson gold heist
Police say one former and one current employee of Air Canada are among the nine suspects that are facing charges in connection with the gold heist at Pearson International Airport last year.
House admonishes ArriveCan contractor in rare parliamentary show of power
MPs enacted an extraordinary, rarely used parliamentary power on Wednesday, summonsing an ArriveCan contractor to appear before the House of Commons where he was admonished publicly and forced to provide answers to the questions MPs said he'd previously evaded.
Leafs star Auston Matthews finishes season with 69 goals
Auston Matthews won't be joining the NHL's 70-goal club this season.
Trump lawyers say Stormy Daniels refused subpoena outside a Brooklyn bar, papers left 'at her feet'
Donald Trump's legal team says it tried serving Stormy Daniels a subpoena as she arrived for an event at a bar in Brooklyn last month, but the porn actor, who is expected to be a witness at the former president's criminal trial, refused to take it and walked away.
Why drivers in Eastern Canada could see big gas price spikes, and other Canadians won't
Drivers in Eastern Canada face a big increase in gas prices because of various factors, especially the higher cost of the summer blend, industry analysts say.
Doug Ford calls on Ontario Speaker to reverse Queen's Park keffiyeh ban
Ontario Premier Doug Ford is calling on Speaker Ted Arnott to reverse a ban on keffiyehs at Queen's Park, describing the move as “needlessly” divisive.
'A living nightmare': Winnipeg woman sentenced following campaign of harassment against man after online date
A Winnipeg woman was sentenced to house arrest after a single date with a man she met online culminated in her harassing him for years, and spurred false allegations which resulted in the innocent man being arrested three times.
Woman who pressured boyfriend to kill his ex in 2000s granted absences from prison
A woman who pressured her boyfriend into killing his teenage ex more than a decade ago will be allowed to leave prison for weeks at a time.
Customers disappointed after email listing $60K Tim Hortons prize sent in error
Several Tim Horton’s customers are feeling great disappointment after being told by the company that an email stating they won a boat worth nearly $60,000 was sent in error.