Judge rejects Thorneloe’s effort to revive $9.8M claim against Laurentian
An Ontario court has rejected Thorneloe University’s efforts to revive its financial claim against Laurentian University.
Thorneloe, along with the University of Sudbury and Huntington University, operated for decades under a federated university agreement with LU.
But when Laurentian declared insolvency in February 2021, it renounced the agreement, claiming it was losing too much money under the terms of the deal.
It reached a settlement with Huntington, but the University of Sudbury and Thorneloe went through the claims process, seeking compensation.
The monitor of LU’s insolvency rejected Thorneloe’s claim of $9.8 million in losses, ruling it was owed nothing.
Lawyers for Thorneloe then appealed to Chief Justice G.B. Morawetz, the chief justice of Ontario’s Superior Court of Justice. Morawetz is the judge that oversaw LU’s insolvency process under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act.
The appeal was heard earlier this month. Thorneloe’s lawyers argued that the court should be guided by a report prepared by “expert valuator,” Glenn Bowman of Farber Corporate Finance Inc.
That report estimated Thorneloe’s operating enterprise value to be worth $2.8 million and $3.3 million, along with other assets (mostly cash and cash equivalents) of $6.7 million.
“Thorneloe submits that when an entity has been destroyed by the actions of another such as by a breach of contract, the required approach to assess damages is the loss of commercial value approach,” the court transcript said.
“Thorneloe submits that the case law supports the proposition that even if the business is unprofitable it can still have value.”
In response, the monitor argued that the university lost money in each of the four years before LU declared insolvency. Losses ranged from more than $90,000 in 2018 to $1.15 million in 2021.
It also criticized the Farber report for not actually assessing the damages caused by LU’s ending of the federated university agreement.
“Instead, the Farber report presented a visibly flawed approach not based on the economic reality of Thorneloe,” the document said.
“This flawed approach sought to present a value for the business, the majority of which was the assets they retained, and the operational value based on the revenue earned versus the actual operating cash flow, which in all recent periods was negative.”
Further, the monitor argued that Thorneloe still had possession of its $6.7 million in investments, which were unaffected by the insolvency process.
“Additionally, the disclaimer does not prevent Thorneloe from continuing operation of its residences and, in fact, Thorneloe has continued to operate its residences,” the transcript said.
“Finally, the monitor submits that there has not been any evidence provided to support a decrease in the profitability of Thorneloe’s residences operation being caused by the disclaimer.”
In the end, the judge ruled that the Farber report falsely gave the impression that Thorneloe was profitable when it was not.
“The Farber report does not consider Thorneloe’s net cash flows – i.e. revenues net of expenses,” the judge ruled.
“Because Thorneloe’s net cash flow is reasonably expected to continue to be negative, it is not entitled to claim the loss of academic and commercial value.”
Read the full transcript here.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Hackers release corporate data stolen from London Drugs
Retailer London Drugs says cybercriminals who stole files from its corporate head office last month have released some of the data after it refused to pay a ransom.
Toronto man falls off his chair after seeing $70M Lotto Max win in his bank account
A Toronto man who won $70 million in a recent Lotto Max draw literally fell off his chair when he saw the funds in his bank account.
Montreal-area high school students protest 'sexist' dress code
Approximately 50 Montreal-area students — the vast majority of them female — were suspended Wednesday after their school deemed the shorts they were wearing were too short. On Thursday, several students staged a walk-out to protest what they believe is a "sexist" dress code that unfairly targets girls.
'Looking over our shoulders': A killing looms large in a little B.C. town
Something shifted in the pretty little village of Lumby, B.C., after Tatjana Stefanski vanished. It used to be the sort of place where parents let their kids roam free or play in the local creek, but everything has changed.
'I won't stop,' Celine Dion says in trailer for upcoming doc about her health woes
Celine Dion's fans are getting a first glimpse of the superstar's struggle with a rare neurological disorder in an emotional trailer for an upcoming documentary about her career and life.
Tim Meadows pledges not to shave until the Oilers win the cup, who are the team's other famous fans?
An unlikely celebrity emerged from social media to cheer on the Edmonton Oilers as they face the Dallas Stars tonight in Game 1 of the Western Conference Finals.
American Airlines retreats after blaming a 9-year-old for not seeing a hidden camera in a lavatory
American Airlines has distanced itself from a court filing in which the carrier said a nine-year-old girl should have noticed there was a camera taped to the seat of an airplane lavatory.
Luxury beauty brand Clarins to pull out of Hudson's Bay stores in Canada
French luxury makeup and skincare brand Clarins is pulling out of Hudson's Bay stores in Canada.
'It's over': Minister says B.C.'s decision on Surrey police transition upheld in court
The B.C. Supreme Court has ruled in the provincial government's favour on the City of Surrey's legal challenge to its ongoing transition to a municipal police force, according to B.C. Minister of Public Safety and Solicitor General Mike Farnworth.