Judge rejects Thorneloe’s effort to revive $9.8M claim against Laurentian
An Ontario court has rejected Thorneloe University’s efforts to revive its financial claim against Laurentian University.
Thorneloe, along with the University of Sudbury and Huntington University, operated for decades under a federated university agreement with LU.
But when Laurentian declared insolvency in February 2021, it renounced the agreement, claiming it was losing too much money under the terms of the deal.
It reached a settlement with Huntington, but the University of Sudbury and Thorneloe went through the claims process, seeking compensation.
The monitor of LU’s insolvency rejected Thorneloe’s claim of $9.8 million in losses, ruling it was owed nothing.
Lawyers for Thorneloe then appealed to Chief Justice G.B. Morawetz, the chief justice of Ontario’s Superior Court of Justice. Morawetz is the judge that oversaw LU’s insolvency process under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act.
The appeal was heard earlier this month. Thorneloe’s lawyers argued that the court should be guided by a report prepared by “expert valuator,” Glenn Bowman of Farber Corporate Finance Inc.
That report estimated Thorneloe’s operating enterprise value to be worth $2.8 million and $3.3 million, along with other assets (mostly cash and cash equivalents) of $6.7 million.
“Thorneloe submits that when an entity has been destroyed by the actions of another such as by a breach of contract, the required approach to assess damages is the loss of commercial value approach,” the court transcript said.
“Thorneloe submits that the case law supports the proposition that even if the business is unprofitable it can still have value.”
In response, the monitor argued that the university lost money in each of the four years before LU declared insolvency. Losses ranged from more than $90,000 in 2018 to $1.15 million in 2021.
It also criticized the Farber report for not actually assessing the damages caused by LU’s ending of the federated university agreement.
“Instead, the Farber report presented a visibly flawed approach not based on the economic reality of Thorneloe,” the document said.
“This flawed approach sought to present a value for the business, the majority of which was the assets they retained, and the operational value based on the revenue earned versus the actual operating cash flow, which in all recent periods was negative.”
Further, the monitor argued that Thorneloe still had possession of its $6.7 million in investments, which were unaffected by the insolvency process.
“Additionally, the disclaimer does not prevent Thorneloe from continuing operation of its residences and, in fact, Thorneloe has continued to operate its residences,” the transcript said.
“Finally, the monitor submits that there has not been any evidence provided to support a decrease in the profitability of Thorneloe’s residences operation being caused by the disclaimer.”
In the end, the judge ruled that the Farber report falsely gave the impression that Thorneloe was profitable when it was not.
“The Farber report does not consider Thorneloe’s net cash flows – i.e. revenues net of expenses,” the judge ruled.
“Because Thorneloe’s net cash flow is reasonably expected to continue to be negative, it is not entitled to claim the loss of academic and commercial value.”
Read the full transcript here.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
DEVELOPING 122 active wildfires burning across Canada, 32 considered 'out of control'
The 2024 wildfire season has begun, and it's shaping up to follow last year's unprecedented destruction in kind, with thousands of square kilometres already consumed.
B.C. parents sentenced to 15 years for death of 6-year-old boy
A British Columbia Supreme Court judge has sentenced the mother and stepfather of a six-year-old boy who died from blunt-force trauma in 2018 to 15 years in prison.
Veteran TSN sportscaster Darren Dutchyshen has died
Veteran TSN broadcaster Darren 'Dutch' Dutchyshen, one of Canada’s best-known sports journalists, has died. He was 57. His family says 'he passed as he was surrounded by his closest loved ones.'
Police issue Canada-wide warrant for Regina homicide suspect
Police have issued a Canada-wide warrant for a man wanted in a homicide which occurred in Regina on May 12.
Kevin Spacey receives star support as he fights to get his career back
Kevin Spacey is pushing back on the 'rush to judgment' against him and is being backed by some big names as he seeks to reclaim his acting career.
Speaker cuts ties with Sask. Party, alleges he faced threats, harassment from gov't MLAs
The Speaker of the Saskatchewan Legislature Randy Weekes has severed ties with the Sask. Party after accusing some members of harassment and intimidation tactics, including a situation he claimed saw the Government House Leader bring a hunting rifle to the legislative building.
Trudeau calls New Brunswick's Conservative government a 'disgrace' on women's rights
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau assailed New Brunswick's premier and other conservative leaders on Thursday, calling out the provincial government's position on abortion, LGBTQ youth and climate change.
A Toronto man killed his mother and decapitated her. His lawyers argue it wasn't murder
A ‘lifetime of abuse’ led Dallas Ly to snap and repeatedly stab his mother inside their Leslieville apartment in 2022 but he never intended to kill her, his defence lawyers argued during his murder trial in Toronto on Thursday.
Father charged with second-degree murder in daughter's stabbing death southwest of Montreal
A father has been charged with second-degree murder in the stabbing death of his 34-year-old daughter in southern Quebec.