Lawyers for Laurentian, auditor general, get their day in court
Lawyers for Laurentian University and the auditor general of Ontario appeared before Superior Court Chief Justice Geoffrey Morawetz on Monday morning in an effort to resolve a dispute related to access to information.
The case centres on whether LU has to give Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk access to confidential documents and information normally covered by solicitor-client privilege.
Lysyk is conducting a value-for-money audit in the wake of the university declaring insolvency in February. She argues that Section 10.3 of the Auditor General Act of Ontario, amended in 2004, gives her the power to access those documents.
The section was amended to apply the auditor general's oversight to institutions in Ontario that receive funding from the province.
The amended section reads as follows: "A disclosure to the auditor general under subsection (1) or (2) does not constitute a waiver of solicitor-client privilege, litigation privilege or settlement privilege."
In response, lawyers for Laurentian argued that section gives them the option, not the obligation, to surrender those documents. If the Ontario Legislature meant to override solicitor-client privilege, they argue, the legislation would have said so explicitly.
On Monday, lawyer Richard Dearden, representing the auditor's office, argued that previous court decisions have ruled that the privilege is not absolute. And language in the act clearly shows the intent to allow the auditor to access any information needed to complete her work.
"Yes, it could have been clearer," Dearden said. "(But) it's clear the legislature intended solicitor-client information would be included … What else could they mean?"
He said there are safeguards in place to protect the information, further showing the legislature's intent. He said the idea that turning over that information is optional is "unreasonable."
Otherwise, he said "(Section) 10.3 would be deprived of functional meaning."
He said the first two parts of the section – granting access to information to "Auditor General believes to be necessary to perform his or her duties" – combined with section three shows the intent of the legislation.
"Section 10 read as a whole in my submission provides the auditor general right of access to a grant recipient's privileged information, documents read as a whole," Dearden said.
"So it's actually (Sections) one, two and three."
In response, Brian Gover, the lawyer representing Laurentian, said the only issue to be resolved is whether the act gives the auditor general the power to compel an organization being audited to hand over privileged documents.
Gover said that's one of the fundamental rights of the justice system.
"Everyone has the right to consult with their lawyers in private -- privilege is a fundamental civil and constitutional right," he said.
Must be absolutely necessary
"It is a principle of fundamental justice. Exceptions from that principle must be rare, narrow and justified by absolute necessity."
Such exceptions must be made explicit in any piece of legislation, he argued.
"And you've heard Mr. Dearden say in response to you, chief justice this morning, (the legislation) could have been clearer," Gover said.
"(The legislation) does not say that an audit subject must disclose privileged information to the auditor-general."
There are three other acts that do require parties to disclose privileged information, and do so explicitly. That's not the case here, he said.
Gover said should the court rule in favour of the auditor, the next step would be an appeal arguing the auditor general legislation violates the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
"But we are not there yet," he said.
Forcing an organization to hand over privileged documents would increase the likelihood of it being made public, Gover said.
"There's more than a possibility of those things happening," he said.
"The auditor general uses the information to inform her report, even if she does not disclose it directly, even if she does not quote it directly. And staff will have access … It just takes one mistake for privileged information to be disclosed forever."
Many people are viewing this case as Laurentian trying to keep information secret, Gover said, and that is not what is at stake.
"Solicitor-client privilege is not a lawyer's trick to avoid proper scrutiny of her client's conduct," he said.
"It would be wrong to conclude that the result in this case, represents the triumph of secrecy over transparency and accountability. It rather represents the reaffirmation of a principle, which is a cornerstone value in our democracy and, which has been so for hundreds of years."
Morawetz said he would take some time to reach his decision, referencing a busy court docket, but added he would release his ruling as quickly as possible.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING Monthly earnings rise, payroll employment falls: jobs report
The number of vacant jobs in Canada increased in February, while monthly payroll employment decreased in food services, manufacturing, and retail trade, among other sectors.
Doctors say capital gains tax changes will jeopardize their retirement. Is that true?
The Canadian Medical Association asserts the Liberals' proposed changes to capital gains taxation will put doctors' retirement savings in jeopardy, but some financial experts insist incorporated professionals are not as doomed as they say they are.
Remains from a mother-daughter cold case were found nearly 24 years later, after a deathbed confession from the suspect
A West Virginia father is getting some sense of closure after authorities found the remains of his young daughter and her mother following a deathbed confession from the man believed to have fatally shot them nearly two decades ago.
Something in the water? Canadian family latest to spot elusive 'Loch Ness Monster'
For centuries, people have wondered what, if anything, might be lurking beneath the surface of Loch Ness in Scotland. When Canadian couple Parry Malm and Shannon Wiseman visited the Scottish highlands earlier this month with their two children, they didn’t expect to become part of the mystery.
What do weight loss drugs mean for a diet industry built on eating less and exercising more?
Recent injected drugs like Wegovy and its predecessor, the diabetes medication Ozempic, are reshaping the health and fitness industries.
2 military horses that broke free and ran loose across London are in serious condition
Two military horses that bolted and ran miles through the streets of London after being spooked by construction noise and tossing their riders were in a serious condition and required operations, a British government official said Thursday.
'It was instant karma': Viral video captures failed theft attempt in Nanaimo, B.C.
Mounties in Nanaimo, B.C., say two late-night revellers are lucky their allegedly drunken antics weren't reported to police after security cameras captured the men trying to steal a heavy sign from a downtown business.
Fair in Ontario, flurries in Labrador: Weather systems make for an erratic spring
It's no secret that spring can be a tumultuous time for Canadian weather, and as an unseasonably mild El Nino winter gives way to summer, there's bound to be a few swings in temperature that seem out of the ordinary. From Ontario to the Atlantic, though, this week is about to feel a little erratic.
He replaced Mickey Mantle. Now baseball's oldest living major leaguer is turning 100
The oldest living former major leaguer, Art Schallock turns 100 on Thursday and is being celebrated in the Bay Area and beyond as the milestone approaches.