Lawsuit reveals behind-the-scenes conflict between leaders of Sudbury non-profit groups
Court documents show that the people behind two non-profit groups in Greater Sudbury who fight for the vulnerable have been warring between themselves in court for the last few years.
Both groups help victims of crime, but the individuals leading each organization are embroiled in lawsuits working their way through the legal system.
At issue is a dispute between the people behind Sudbury and Area Victim Services (SAVS) and the leader of Angels of Hope Against Human Trafficking (AOHAHT), two groups in the city with related mandates.
SAVS is an agency created by the Ministry of the Attorney General that works to help victims of crime, while AOHAHT is focused on helping victims of human trafficking.
“Suffice it to say theirs has been a relationship marred by conflict,” said a court transcript of the latest decision in the case.
The dispute dates to April 14, 2020, when AOHAHT executive director Cristina Scarpellini sent a “cease and desist” letter to SAVS executive director Erica McDonald-Gertz and Nicole St-Jean, who leads the human trafficking initiative at SAVS.
The letter was also sent to the SAVS board of directors and the ministry.
It’s important to note that none of the allegations mentioned in the lawsuit have been proven in court.
The letter accused McDonald-Gertz and St-Jean of making “defamatory and libellous” statements about Scarpellini.
The statements, Scarpellini alleged, included five main accusations: that she was using drugs at an open forum; that AOHAHT is not trustworthy; that AOHAHT has mishandled money; that fraud was happening at the organization; and, that Scarpellini “was crazy, unstable, and psychologically unwell and should not be working in the social service field.”
In response, McDonald-Gertz and St-Jean had their lawyer send Scarpellini a letter that denied anyone from their organization made those statements and demanded a retraction.
When they received no reply, the pair filed a statement of claim in court, alleging Scarpellini’s letter was defamatory, that SAVS depends on its reputation to deliver services to clients and that publishing the letter “had caused harm.”
In response, Scarpellini’s lawyer filed a statement of defence and counter-claim, largely based on the allegations listed in the letter. The counter-claim “sought general and special damages, aggravated damages, and punitive damages for defamation and injurious falsehood,” said a transcription of the court decision.
Her lawyer, Monty Dhaliwal, also filed what’s known as an ‘Anti-SLAPP’ (strategic lawsuit against public participation) in an attempt to have the lawsuit dismissed.
Anti-SLAPP laws are aimed at preventing lawsuits by larger organizations that have no prospect of succeeding and are primarily aimed at silencing the defendant.
To succeed in an Anti-SLAPP motion, a defendant has to convince the judge that the issue is related to public interest, that the lawsuit doesn’t have merit and is largely intended to intimidate the defendant.
In the case against Scarpellini, her lawyer sought to have the lawsuit dismissed, to have her legal costs covered as well as an award for damages of $50,000.
“The defendant submits that the letter was an expression made on a matter of public interest – namely, protecting her reputation and the reputation of AOH(AHT) as service providers to members of the public who are victims of human trafficking; and, limiting the damage to her and to AOH(AHT) which may be caused by the disputed statements,” the court decision said.
But the lawyer for McDonald-Gertz and St-Jean replied that the motion to dismiss is a misuse of Anti-SLAPP laws.
“They submit that it was the defendant who defamed the plaintiffs by issuing a letter containing false allegations to the SAVS board and the ministry,” the decision said.
“They argue that the defendant forced them to seek relief from the court by failing to retract the letter.”
If the Anti-SLAPP motion succeeded, “they will be defenseless not only against the defamatory allegations in the letter but against future harassment by the defendant. They submit that dismissing their claim would be tantamount to sanctioning the defendant’s conduct.”
In response, Scarpellini’s lawyer argued that this was another attempt “by the plaintiffs to silence and discredit her.
“She argues that it is in the public interest that her ability to provide services to victims of human trafficking be protected, and that she be granted relief against the plaintiffs for interfering with her ability to provide those services. She submits that granting her motion will send a clear message to the plaintiffs that they cannot abuse their positions within SAVS to the detriment of the defendant, her organization and her clients.”
In her decision, which was released May 15, Justice K.E. Cullin wrote that the first thing she had to decide was whether Scarpellini’s letter could be reasonably viewed as “defamatory.”
“The plaintiffs say that the letter accused them of lying about the defendant and AOH(AHT),” the judge wrote.
“In addition to any impact within the community, they allege that the letter has harmed their relationship with their employer and its government funding agency.”
Cullin ruled there was a reasonable argument to be made that the intent of the letter sent by Scarpellini “was motivated, in whole or in part, by spite, malice, ill-will or ulterior purpose.”
“It is clear from the evidence that there was animus between the plaintiffs and the defendant and that the defendant had publicly aired grievances against the plaintiffs on prior occasions, at times inappropriately,” the judge wrote.
“It would not be difficult for a court to conclude that the communication of the letter was made with the ulterior purpose of causing discord in the relationship between the plaintiffs and their superiors.”
Cullin said that it is clear that AOHAHT and SAVS have a poor relationship that has only gotten worse.
“Separate and apart from the letter and this claim, each side has made prior accusations and allegations against the other,” Cullin said.
“This litigation is the culmination of that conflict.”
Considering the important role both organizations play in the community, she ruled that it was in the public’s interest to allow the lawsuit against Scarpellini to continue.
o Download our app to get local alerts on your device
o Get the latest local updates right to your inbox
“The parties’ conflict has trickled into both their delivery of services and their relationships with community partners,” Cullin said.
“I find that it is in the public interest to permit this proceeding to continue either to resolution or adjudication on a full evidentiary record. Ultimately, either the parties will settle upon a framework within which they can co-exist or their organizations, community partners and funding bodies will receive a ruling which will allow them to identify the source of the conflict, take corrective action, and forge a path forward. Only then will the public interest be served.”
She concluded her ruling by urging both sides to try and resolve their differences in a case conference.
CTV News sought comment from lawyers representing both sides of the case.
Dhaliwal, lawyer for Scarpellini, sent us a statement in response that said, in part:
“Notwithstanding the results of the Anti-SLAPP motion, Cristina continues to vehemently deny the allegations made against her and feels that she is the one who has been defamed by the plaintiffs. She will defend herself in court.”
“This is a complex dispute between private individuals which involved volumes of evidence before the court. It is also material to understand that AOHAHT and SAAVS are not litigants in this dispute.”
Read the full decision here.
While court documents list the acronym for Angels of Hope Against Human Trafficking as AOH, CTV News has updated the article above to AOHAHT to avoid confusion after a request by Ancient Order of Hibernians who also uses the acronym AOH and is not at all connected to the story.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Hundreds of American firefighters arrive in Canada to help battle wildfires
Hundreds of American firefighters have recently arrived in Canada to help battle wildfires and more are on the way, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said Wednesday.
Can face masks help protect you from wildfire smoke? Health expert explains
An official recommendation to wear a mask to protect yourself from wildfire smoke is being echoed by health experts as plumes of smoke make their way across parts of Canada, causing poor air quality.
Here's how major cities in Canada and the U.S. look blanketed by wildfire smoke
Photos show smoke-filled skies in cities across Canada and the U.S. as air quality warnings were issued in wake of the hundreds of wildfires from Quebec and Ontario.
'Very, very hard to breathe': Experts call wildfires a 'major public health concern' for Canada
As forest fires rage across the country, experts are sounding the alarm over the physical and psychological impacts of the wildfires and saying that they pose a serious public health issue, which individuals and governments need to acknowledge and act upon.
WATCH | Rate hike 'may be the last straw' for some homeowners: mortgage broker
With the latest hike bringing Canada's key interest rates to levels not seen since 2001, one mortgage broker is warning that it may be 'the last straw' for some homeowners with variable mortgages.
Canadians more likely to support foreign interference inquiry than hearings: Nanos
Canadians are twice as likely to support a formal inquiry into foreign interference, as opposed to public hearings, according to new polling from Nanos Research for CTV News.
opinion | Eight takeaways from Prince Harry's seven hours on the witness stand
It's been a busy, tumultuous few days for Prince Harry, the Duke of Sussex as he took his place on the witness stand in his trial against the Mirror Group Newspapers. Here are royal commentator Afua Hagan's top takeaways from his two-day grilling.
Calgary mass killer Matthew de Grood seeks 'absolute discharge'
The man who was found not criminally responsible in the stabbing deaths of five people at a house party in Brentwood more than nine years ago is seeking more freedoms.
Trudeau shows no interest in compromising with Meta, Google over online news bill
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is showing no interest in compromising with Meta and Google over a Liberal bill that would make them pay for Canadian journalism that helps the companies generate revenue.
Simcoe County working towards plan to address homelessness
Like many regions across the country, Simcoe County is working towards a solution to end homelessness and create more affordable housing.
Multiple 1,000lb pieces of construction equipment stolen from Barrie site
Police in Barrie are investigating after construction equipment was allegedly stolen from an active site in the city's south end.
Bradford stabbing called 'hate-related' by police
South Simcoe police have one suspect in custody involved in what they call a "hate-related" stabbing in the Town of Bradford West Gwillimbury.
consumer, | Toronto woman 'horrified' after losing $95,000 to romance scam
Romance scams have always been around, but they got worse during the pandemic, and fraudsters continue to use social media and dating sites to find victims.
Number of Ontario forest fires doubled compared to same time last year
Ontario has already experienced double the number of forest fires this year compared to the same six months in 2022.
Alleged Toronto anti-cyclist road rage incident caught on camera
Toronto police are investigating an incident of alleged road rage against a cyclist that was caught on camera.
Special Air Quality Statement
Special Air Quality Statement | Wildfire smoke blankets Ottawa for a third day
Environment Canada has issued a special air quality statement for Ottawa, with the air quality at 10+ "very high risk" Wednesday morning. Conditions improved in the afternoon.
Plug-in air purifier blamed for row house fire in Craig Henry area
The Ottawa Fire Service says a plug-in air purifier is to blame for a fire on Craig Henry Drive Tuesday.
Centennial Lake fire being held; evacuation order in place until Friday
The wildfire at Centennial Lake, 150 km west of Ottawa, is being held by firefighters, but an evacuation order remains in effect until Friday.
Poor air quality in Waterloo region and Guelph will continue into the weekend: Environment Canada
There's high levels of air pollution in Waterloo region and Wellington County as smoke plumes from wildfires burning in Quebec and northeastern Ontario continue to blow into the region, Environment Canada says.
Six Region of Waterloo councillors announce support for amalgamation
One unified city – that’s what six Region of Waterloo councillors say they want when it comes to the future of the region’s municipal governance.
Habitat for Humanity nears completion of new affordable housing units
The work never stops at Habitat for Humanity when it comes to building affordable homes for families in Waterloo region.
VIDEO | 'Hate and discrimination have no place in any TVDSB schools': Investigation underway after pride flag torn down
Students at Sir Frederick Banting Secondary School in London, Ont. are being investigated after a video was posted online showing students tearing down a LGBTQ2S+ pride flag.
Special air quality statement remains in effect, rain possible over the weekend
As wildfire smoke blankets Ontario and eastern U.S., causing hazardous air quality and hazy skies, smoke in the Forest City is expected to remain until at least Thursday night.
City pitches new parking garage and extended free parking to aid downtown London, Ont.’s recovery
Since early in the COVID-19 pandemic, the Honk Mobile Parking App has offered two hours of free municipal parking in London’s core area business districts.
Weapon and drug charges laid after Lakeshore ‘road rage’ incident
A “road rage” incident has led to multiple charges for two Windsor residents after allegedly wielding a replica firearm at another driver.
'I just feel so empty': Mother opens up after teenaged daughter’s body recovered by police
The body of a woman reported missing in January has been found by Windsor police and her mother is struggling with the confirmation that her daughter is gone.
Alleged murder of Windsor woman marks region's 4th case of femicide in last two years, says advocacy group
In the wake of a first-degree murder charge being filed against a Michigan man for killing his estranged wife, a 36-year-old Windsor woman, the head of an emergency shelter for women and children says femicide is a growing problem in Windsor-Essex.
Ontario man charged with first-degree murder in killing of Claudia Iacono outside Montreal salon
An Ontario man has been charged with first-degree murder in the death of Claudia Iacono, the daughter-in-law of Mafia associate Moreno Gallo, after she was gunned down at the wheel of her car in Montreal last month.
Woman, 55, dies after vehicle strikes 2 pedestrians in Cote-des-Neiges; second pedestrian seriously injured
A pedestrian has died after she and a fellow pedestrian were both hit by a vehicle Wednesday afternoon in Montreal's Cote-des-Neiges neighbourhood.
More evacuations in Quebec as record-breaking fires continue to burn
Quebec's wildfire season, which has forced thousands from their homes and left other communities on high alert, is the worst on record, officials said Wednesday,
'This is not helping': Frustrated evacuees say official communication lacking in wildfire recovery
Frustration is building among some people from neighbourhoods hardest-hit by the fires near Halifax. CTV's Heidi Petracek reports.
A 'whole list of hazards' are keeping residents near N.S. fire zones under evacuation: officials
It is still not safe for some evacuated residents whose houses were spared from wildfire damage to return home, officials from Halifax Regional Municipality and the District of Shelburne said.
Halifax support workers strike impacting students and families
The father of disabled teen from Fall River, N.S. is calling on all sides to get back to the bargaining table and put an end to the Halifax area CUPE educational support worker strike.
Trustee suspended over posts targeting LGBTQ2S+ community, division says
A Manitoba school trustee has been suspended over social media posts the division says targeted the LGBTQ2S+ community.
Continued closure of Fort Gibraltar causing changes for soon to be married couples
The closure of Fort Gibraltar following the collapse of an elevated walkway that sent 16 students and one teacher to hospital has left some couples scrambling to find a place to get married.
Crash with stolen vehicle sends two Winnipeg officers to hospital
A section of Main Street is closed on Wednesday morning following a car crash in the area.
Council reconsiders decision to reject recommendations on affordability crisis
Calgary city council has reconsidered its decision to vote against recommendations made by an expert panel to address the city’s housing affordability crisis.
Hot, dry weather comes with cautions and a few benefits
Calgary was under a heat warning Wednesday with forecast high of 29C.
Documentary series examines story of missing Marshal Iwaasa
Marshal Iwaasa disappeared three and a half years ago and the mystery of what happened to him is now part of a streaming documentary series.
Albertans asked to conserve electricity Wednesday evening due to hot temperatures
Hot temperatures across Alberta prompted a grid alert Wednesday afternoon.
'A long time coming': Edmonton Catholics commit $3.2M to Indigenous reconciliation fund
The Archdiocese of Edmonton will spend $3.2 million on reconciliation initiatives with First Nations, Métis and Inuit people in the Alberta capital region.
'Major travel delays': Anthony Henday Drive bridge will be closed this weekend
Drivers are being asked to find another way or prepare for delays on the Henday this weekend, because crews need to close a bridge over the North Saskatchewan River.
Out-of-control wildfire on Lower Mainland sees massive growth
A human-caused wildfire on the Lower Mainland has grown to an estimated 800 hectares and continues to burn out of control Wednesday, according to the BC Wildfire Service.
'You don't listen to renters': Vancouver Tenants Union disrupts housing announcement
Rental housing advocates interrupted an announcement by B.C.'s housing minister in Vancouver Wednesday morning to object to the provincial government's response to the affordability crisis.
Air quality advisory in effect for Metro Vancouver, Fraser Valley
An air quality advisory is in effect for parts of Metro Vancouver and the Fraser Valley as wildfire smoke and high temperatures create hazy, potentially hazardous conditions.