Family sues OPP, others, for more than $2M after woman dies in Sudbury, Ont., jail
The family of a woman who died by suicide in November 2020 while incarcerated at the Sudbury Jail is suing police and other officials for more than $2 million.
The family of Justine Nicole Docherty alleged in its statement of claim that police knew she had mental health challenges and was threatening to end her own life, yet they left her in a cell without taking special precautions.
The suit is filed on behalf of several family members, including Docherty’s two children. It seeks $500,000 in general damages, $100,000 each for 17 family members listed in the suit, as well as other damages determined by the Superior Court of Justice.
No allegations listed in the suit have been proven in court and no statement of defence has been filed.
The suit details a timeline of events that led to Docherty’s death in jail Nov. 1, 2020.
She was wanted Oct. 13 of that year on outstanding charges by Ontario Provincial Police in Bracebridge, along with a second person.
“On or about Oct. 19, 2020, she voluntarily turned herself in to Orillia OPP,” the statement of claim said.
“Justine was taken to the Central North Correction Centre in Penetanguishene to await a bail hearing. After several days in custody, Justine was released on bail with conditions that she reside with her father Earl Docherty and abide by the rules of his house. At the time, Earl Docherty was in the process of moving from Orillia, Ont., to Sudbury, Ont.”
While she was in Sudbury, her father became concerned that she wasn’t abiding by her bail conditions and considered revoking himself as her surety.
“He decided to go with Justine to the Bracebridge OPP station to obtain information regarding his options,” the court document said.
“On or around Oct. 28, 2020, Earl was driving Justine to the Bracebridge police station when she suddenly fled the vehicle.”
At that point, her father contacted Bracebridge OPP, who asked Earl whether his daughter was suicidal. He suggested they ask Justine’s sister, Ashley.
“During the relevant time, Ashley had received several text messages from Justine advising that she was suicidal and that she would kill herself if she had to go back to jail,” the lawsuit said.
The Sudbury Jail, which is currently undergoing $10 million in renovations, was "vastly overcrowded and understaffed" at the time of Justine Docherty's death in November 2020, a lawsuit alleges. (File)
“Ashley reported Justine’s suicidal ideation to the Bracebridge OPP and further advised that Justine had a history of mental illness. A large-scale search for Justine was undertaken by Bracebridge OPP with the knowledge she had breached her bail conditions, that she was suffering a mental health condition and that she was suicidal.”
OPP in Orillia then reported they had pulled over a vehicle in which Justine was a passenger. Police in Bracebridge told Earl she was being taken to hospital in Orillia for a mental-health evaluation.
“However, Orillia OPP did not arrest Justine, nor take her to (hospital), despite OPP awareness of Justine’s breach, her mental health condition and her suicidal ideation,” the lawsuit said.
ALLOWED HER TO DRIVE AWAY
“Instead, (they) allowed her to drive away with her two friends. Justine then headed to Sudbury where she stayed at a hotel.”
She was taken into custody by Sudbury police Oct. 30 and placed in the Sudbury Jail, but not placed on a special watch despite her mental health condition.
“The plaintiffs state that the Sudbury police were aware or ought to have been aware of Justine’s mental health condition including her suicidal ideation,” the lawsuit said.
“The Sudbury police officers involved failed to bring Justine for an assessment and/or failed to properly communicate her reported mental health issues including her suicidal ideation to officials with the Sudbury Jail or others who may have assisted her.”
The suit also accuses staff at the Sudbury Jail of failing to live up to their responsibilities to protect her while she was incarcerated.
“The Sudbury Jail is a 100-year-old provincial institution operated by the Crown through the ministry,” the lawsuit said.
“It originally was built to house a much smaller population. At the relevant time, it was vastly overcrowded and understaffed.”
The suit said Docherty was placed in an inadequately supervised cell by herself. She was not placed on suicide watch and there were no cameras inside the cell.
“Guards who toured the area did so at predictable times and not at irregular intervals as required,” the lawsuit said.
“Justine was able to predict when she would be unsupervised and thus able to commit suicide. She received no counselling or other assistance in dealing with her mental health crisis.”
The suit was filed Jan. 3 and names the OPP, unnamed police officials and the Greater Sudbury Police Services Board as defendants.
HELP IS AVAILABLE
If you or someone you know is in crisis, here are some resources that are available.
Crisis Services Canada (1-833-456-4566 or text 45645), Centre for Suicide Prevention (1-833-456-4566) or Kids Help Phone (1-800-668-6868) offer ways of getting help if you, or someone you know, may be suffering from mental health issues.
If you need immediate assistance call 911 or go to the nearest hospital.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Experts warn of 'rapid' growth of IBD as number of Canadians diagnosed set to reach 470K by 2035
The number of people in Canada with inflammatory bowel disease is increasing rapidly and is expected to grow to 470,000 by 2035, according to a new report from Crohn's and Colitis Canada
Canada silent on Polish democratic backslide as prime minister visits Ottawa
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is welcoming Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki to Canada Friday as the federal Liberals keep quiet about a democratic backslide in his country.
Poilievre tries to head off PPC vote as Bernier bets on social conservatives
Pierre Poilievre is off to Manitoba to rally Conservative supporters ahead of a byelection that Maxime Bernier is hoping will send him back to Parliament. The far-right People's Party of Canada leader lost his Quebec seat in the 2019 federal vote and lost again in the 2021 election.
Kyiv defences thwart Russia's 6th air assault in 6 days against Ukraine capital
Ukrainian air defences shot down more than 30 Russian cruise missiles and drones in Moscow's sixth air attack in six days on Kyiv, local officials said Friday. The Ukrainian capital was simultaneously attacked from different directions by Iranian-made Shahed drones and cruise missiles from the Caspian region.
Biden trips after speech addressing U.S. Air Force Academy graduates
U.S. President Joe Biden quipped that he got 'sandbagged' Thursday after he tripped and fell -- but was uninjured -- while onstage at the U.S. Air Force Academy graduation.
Hidden camera discovered in washroom at Gatineau, Que. elementary school
Gatineau police say officers responded to a call from staff at l’école l'Oiseau Bleu on Nelligan Street just after 10 a.m. Friday about a camera found in the washroom.
Jordan's crown prince weds scion of Saudi family in royal wedding packed with stars, symbolism
Jordan's crown prince married the scion of a prominent Saudi family on Thursday in a palace ceremony attended by royals and other VIPs from around the world, as massive crowds gathered across the kingdom to celebrate the region's newest power couple.
5 things to know for Friday, June 2, 2023
More Canadians have inflammatory bowel disease, Meta prepares to block news for some Canadians on Facebook and Instagram, and there's a fight for conservative voters in Manitoba.
Meta will test blocking news on Instagram, Facebook for some Canadians
Meta is planning to run a test that will block news for some Canadian users on Facebook and Instagram in response to the Liberal government's controversial online news bill.
Woman dead after three vehicles collided in Vaughan
A woman has died following a three-vehicle collision in Vaughan.
Barrie police warn residents not to hug strangers after 'bizarre theft'
Police in Barrie are warning the public about a "bizarre theft" where the suspects targeted a senior on her property outside her home.
Nixing Canadian experience rule spells opportunity for Ontario foreign engineers, workers say
Accessible Community Counselling and Employment Services, a charity that supports internationally trained engineers like Zaitsev, said the dropping of the Canadian experience requirement is a welcome development.
Counterfeits, photocopies: Toronto police crack down on accessible parking permit fraud
Toronto police are cracking down on drivers misusing the accessible permits.
Average home price in GTA ticked up in May as demand continues to outpace supply: TRREB
The average selling price of a home in the Greater Toronto Area ticked up again last month as supply continues to lag behind growing demand, the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board says.
Man accused of threatening to shoot Toronto mayoral candidates arrested
A man who allegedly threatened to shoot mayoral candidates that led to the cancellation of Thursday’s debate has been arrested.
Some Ottawa parents keep kids home from school due to Pride activities, OCDSB says
As the Rainbow flag flew at schools across Ottawa on Thursday, the public school board says some parents kept their children home from school due to possible Pride activities.
Iranian family living in Ottawa faces homelessness after falling out of status
An Iranian family living in Ottawa is desperately pleading for help and struggling to stay in Canada with their two young kids, after falling out of status and losing their jobs.
NEW THIS MORNING
NEW THIS MORNING | What's happening in Ottawa this weekend: June 2-4
CTVNewsOttawa.ca looks at things to do in Ottawa, eastern Ontario and western Quebec during the first weekend in June.
CAUGHT ON CAMERA
CAUGHT ON CAMERA | 'This isn’t going to happen today': Staff at Kitchener business recall how they thwarted attempted robbery
The shocking incident was captured on the store's security cameras.
One person dead, another critically injured in Guelph crash
Police say a man appeared to suffer from a medical incident while driving in Guelph, causing his vehicle to go off the road and hit a woman who was sitting on the grass.
New details in devastating Kitchener townhouse fire
Officials say it could be weeks – or months – before the residents displaced by a Kitchener townhouse fire can return home.
Single-vehicle crash near Muncey
The crash happened around 6 a.m. and according to Strathroy Caradoc fire, at least one person is having to be extracted.
Man known to frequent London wanted on a Canada-wide warrant
OPP are looking for Matthew Daigneault — wanted on a Canada-wide warrant for a breach of statutory release. He is described as a white man about 6’ tall, 243 lbs, with a short/receding hairline.
Two London, Ont. women tackle food insecurity in schools
Many children in Ontario are facing food insecurity, forcing them to rely on food banks for their nutritional needs.
Portion of Howard Avenue now open after lengthy overnight closure
According to Windsor police, there was some type of spill, possibly a cooking oil, from an unknown vehicle that coated the road near the E.C. Row Expressway off ramp.
'Like a house of cards': Defence for accused in murder trial begin closing summations
A Windsor murder trial that started in February and heard from dozens of witnesses is coming to a close as defence lawyers for the accused kicked off their closing summations Thursday.
Verge of a Stellantis battery plant deal? Politicians and leaders weigh in
Windsor-Tecumseh MP Irek Kusmierczyk used a basketball analogy to describe where negotiations stand between the Liberals and Stellantis and guaranteed a Game 7 win.
Calling 311? Bill 96 now requires Montrealers to 'attest' they can get English services
Residents who wish to speak with the City of Montreal by calling 311 now have to attest they can receive services in English because of Bill 96. New provisions of the language law came into effect Thursday.
Shots fired at multiple Crescent Street businesses in downtown Montreal
Montreal police are investigating Friday after shots were fired at multiple buildings on Crescent Street, a popular downtown spot containing restaurants, luxury boutiques and art galleries.
Power restored to most Hydro-Quebec customers after forest fire outages
Power has been restored to most of the Hydro-Quebec customers who lost electricity Thursday due to northern forest fires. By 6:30 a.m. Friday, just 5,350 customers remained powerless, down from 250,000 from the previous day.
N.S. premier calls for urgent, proactive firefighting help from Ottawa
Premier Tim Houston repeated his calls for urgent firefighting help Thursday, asking Ottawa to “be proactive” with aid as multiple wildfires continue to burn out of control.
Waegwoltic Club burns in south-end Halifax
A historic athletic club in south-end Halifax is on fire.
Prospect Road fire 'knocked down,' but not yet under control: Halifax deputy fire chief
Halifax deputy fire chief David Meldrum says a new fire started Thursday afternoon on Prospect Road, near St. Margaret’s Bay Road, and “a large area of forest and brush are involved.”
Winnipeg among parts of Manitoba under heat warning
The mercury is rising in parts of Manitoba including Winnipeg where heat warnings have been issued.
Collapsed platform in Winnipeg's Fort Gibraltar last repaired a decade ago: city
The elevated walkway in Winnipeg's Fort Gibraltar that collapsed during a school field trip, sending 16 children and one adult to hospital, was last repaired a decade ago.
Manitoba premier issues apology for centre for people with intellectual disabilities
Manitoba Premier Heather Stefanson formally apologized in the legislature Thursday to former residents of the Manitoba Developmental Centre, one of the country's last large institutional facilities for people with intellectual disabilities.
Suncor to cut 1,500 jobs by end of year, employees informed Thursday
Suncor Energy Inc. will cut 1,500 jobs by the end of the year, as new CEO Rich Kruger forges ahead with his mandate to reduce costs and improve the company's lagging financial performance.
Mayor, councillor clash during discussion about Calgary's social procurement program
Half a decade after it was pitched at city council, Calgary's strategy to partially evaluate suppliers on social policies is leading to a majority of contracts going to small or medium-sized businesses or groups that have diverse representation.
A standup start to National Indigenous History Month at the Calgary Public Library
If the celebration of Indigenous people and culture starts with a day or a month, Sherry Mckay is fine with that -- it could be what helps others get over their apprehensions.
Northern Alberta residents stay back to help protect community from wildfire
Mike Mercredi is staying back to protect his northern Alberta community from a nearby wildfire after hundreds of people were forced to evacuate the area.
Krispy Kreme planning Alberta expansion, starting in Edmonton
Krispy Kreme will soon have a drive-thru and dine-in location in the Alberta capital, and that's just the beginning, the global doughnut giant and a local developer announced Thursday.
'A seat for everyone': Leduc kicks off 2023 Pride week
Pride week is officially underway in Leduc.
Multiple 'serious assaults' on Downtown Eastside, Vancouver police say
The Vancouver Police Department says an investigation is underway after multiple "serious assaults "on the city's Downtown Eastside Thursday.
Surrey Memorial Hospital crisis: Fraser Health asks other regions for staff
On the heels of a series of town halls with staff, Fraser Health is assessing its hospital network to see who can spare staff for Surrey Memorial Hospital, while asking other health authorities for help.
B.C. seniors face long waits for housing amid affordability crisis
A Musqueam elder who welcomed CTV News into his deteriorating home in late April has yet to move, saying he hasn’t been given options for a place to go that are adequate.