Defence can question former West Nipissing public works manager in fraud lawsuit, judge rules
The defence can question a former public works manager in West Nipissing, a judge hearing a $450,000 lawsuit connected to fraudulent invoices has ruled.
The suit, launched in 2016, is the civil end of a case in which criminal charges were laid and town staffers fired in connection with fraudulent invoices submitted by MX Constructors Ltd., a local construction company.
While the criminal cases have wrapped up, the civil suit is slowly making its way through the court system.
West Nipissing alleges:
- That MX submitted two invoices in the amount of $12,964.13 each in connection with unrelated projects to obtain payment of $25,928.26 in connection with a Dura Patcher machine that the plaintiff had previously refused to pay.
- That MX billed for more winter sand than it supplied.
- That MX billed for more granular material than it supplied on four road projects, namely Michel Road, Bear Lake Road, Promenade du Lac, and North Shore Road.
- That MX only completed 50 per cent of the work for which it billed on the Cache Bay sidewalk replacement project.
As part of its defence, lawyers for MX want to cross-examine Marc Gagnon, one of two senior public works employees with the town who were fired when the scandal emerged and later faced fraud charges.
"In November 2017, after this action was commenced, Steven Morrison, the directing mind of MX, pleaded guilty to charges of fraud and uttering a forged document," the court transcript of the suit said. "During the hearing, he admitted that Mr. Gagnon was involved in those crimes."
But lawyers for West Nipissing argued that the defence has failed to show Gagnon has relevant evidence, or that they can't get evidence from him without examining him.
"Counsel for the plaintiff also submits that, because the defendants have failed to establish the relevance of Mr. Gagnon’s evidence, the defendants also cannot establish that it would be unfair to require them to proceed to trial without it," the transcript said.
Dura Patcher pothole repair But the defence argues that it was Gagnon who directed MX to bill the town for the Dura Patcher pothole repair machine.
Dura Patcher pothole repair
"The defendants have pleaded that MX was directed to render the two invoices in question and the evidence indicates that, if true, it would have been Mr. Gagnon who so directed them," the transcript said.
"Although the defendant, Steven Morrison, pleaded guilty as the directing mind of MX to criminal charges in relation to these invoices, counsel agree that the defendants are not precluded from defending the civil action on the basis that MX was directed by Mr. Gagnon to do what it did."
While there's no evidence Gagnon has knowledge about the remaining three allegations, the judge ruled the defence should have the opportunity to ask.
"Like any witness who has evidence to give regarding one issue, the defendants should be free to examine Mr. Gagnon regarding the other issues to determine whether he has relevant evidence to give on those issues, as well," the judge ruled.
The judge also ruled that Gagnon should be questioned, under oath, before the trial begins.
"In my view, given the central role Mr. Gagnon played in the facts of this case and his status as a witness who might be adverse in interest, or even hostile, to both sides of the dispute, this is one of those extraordinary cases in which his evidence should be taken prior to trial," the transcript said.
"It would be unfair to the defendants to have to call him or face him as a witness for the plaintiff without knowing what he is going to say."
None of the allegations has yet to be proven in civil court. Read the full transcript here.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Quebec nurse had to clean up after husband's death in Montreal hospital
On a night she should have been mourning, a nurse from Quebec's Laurentians region says she was forced to clean up her husband after he died at a hospital in Montreal.
Northern Ont. lawyer who abandoned clients in child protection cases disbarred
A North Bay, Ont., lawyer who abandoned 15 clients – many of them child protection cases – has lost his licence to practise law.
Bank of Canada officials split on when to start cutting interest rates
Members of the Bank of Canada's governing council were split on how long the central bank should wait before it starts cutting interest rates when they met earlier this month.
Maple Leafs fall to Bruins in Game 3, trail series 2-1
Brad Marchand scored twice, including the winner in the third period, and added an assist as the Boston Bruins downed the Toronto Maple Leafs 4-2 to take a 2-1 lead in their first-round playoff series Wednesday
Cuban government apologizes to Montreal-area family after delivering wrong body
Cuba's foreign affairs minister has apologized to a Montreal-area family after they were sent the wrong body following the death of a loved one.
'It was instant karma': Viral video captures failed theft attempt in Nanaimo, B.C.
Mounties in Nanaimo, B.C., say two late-night revellers are lucky their allegedly drunken antics weren't reported to police after security cameras captured the men trying to steal a heavy sign from a downtown business.
What is changing about Canada's capital gains tax and how does it impact me?
The federal government's proposed change to capital gains taxation is expected to increase taxes on investments and mainly affect wealthy Canadians and businesses. Here's what you need to know about the move.
New Indigenous loan guarantee program a 'really big deal,' Freeland says at Toronto conference
Canada's Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland was among the 1,700 delegates attending the two-day First Nations Major Projects Coalition (FNMPC) conference that concluded Tuesday in Toronto.
'Life was not fair to him': Daughter of N.B. man exonerated of murder remembers him as a kind soul
The daughter of a New Brunswick man recently exonerated from murder, is remembering her father as somebody who, despite a wrongful conviction, never became bitter or angry.