Court upholds assault conviction for northern Ont. soccer player who punched opponent in the face
![Soccer game A vicious retaliation punch in a soccer game five years ago in the Sault was aggravated assault, an appeals court has confirmed. (File)](/content/dam/ctvnews/en/images/2024/5/8/soccer-game-1-6878652-1715190183816.jpg)
A vicious retaliation punch in a soccer game five years ago in the Sault was aggravated assault, an appeals court has confirmed.
Joshua Gauthier was playing a match for the BDO team in a recreational league against Adam Erickson and the Jiggerz FC in summer 2019 when the incident took place.
According to the decision from the Court of Appeal for Ontario, about 20 minutes into the game, Erickson and Gauthier were competing for the ball.
Believing Erickson had kicked him in the back of the leg, Gauthier turned around and punched him in the head with a closed fist using his right hand.
Erickson “suffered a fractured orbital bone and a laceration above his right eye that required 18 stitches to close,” the court decision.
Gauthier was charged with aggravated assault. At trial, the judge said the issue to be determined was “did Joshua Gauthier intentionally apply force to Adam Erickson – did he intend on hitting him in the face with his fist?”
Gauthier’s lawyer argued he acted out of self-defence, an argument the trial judge rejected.
“Gauthier’s actions cannot be found to be reasonable in the circumstances,” the judge said.
“Gauthier was taller and heavier than Erickson. Gauthier had other options available to him. He could have kicked the ball out of bounds to stop the play or made a plea to the referee to call an infraction, or called for a substitute to be removed from the game.”
He was sentenced to a 12-month conditional sentence, followed by 24 months of probation.
In appealing the sentence, Gauthier’s lawyer argued the trial judge erred by not accepting the defence argument that the punch was a reflex action.
“The appellant’s punch to Mr. Erickson’s face flowed immediately from Mr. Erickson’s kick to the back of the appellant’s leg and push of his shoulder,” the appeals court decision said.
Gauthier testified that his actions were an involuntary response to him being kicked and shoved. But the trial judge disagreed.
- Download our app to get local alerts on your device
- Get the latest local updates right to your inbox
“The preponderance of the evidence from the witnesses who testified has Gauthier turning around and striking Erickson in the face,” the decision said.
“There does not seem anything involuntary about it and on the evidence, it cannot be said that the actions of Gauthier in striking Erickson were accidental or not purposeful.”
The appeals court upheld that ruling, saying there was no air of reality that the punch was self-defence.
“And there was no air of reality that a punch to the face was reasonable responsive force,” the decision said.
The court also upheld the sentence, saying despite the extenuating circumstances, “given the stated goal of general deterrence, the sentence imposed by the trial judge was entirely fair and we see no error in his reasons.”
Read the full decision here.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.6976926.1721883767!/httpImage/image.png_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.png)
DEVELOPING Alberta's request for federal assistance approved after fast-moving wildfire hit Jasper National Park: Trudeau
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced on social media that Ottawa has approved Alberta's request for federal assistance after a fast-moving wildfire hit Jasper National Park and its townsite late Wednesday.
Loblaw, George Weston to settle class action over bread price-fixing for $500 million
Loblaw Cos. Ltd. and its parent company George Weston Ltd. say they have agreed to pay $500-million to settle a class-action lawsuit regarding their involvement in an alleged bread price-fixing scheme.
EXCLUSIVE One address, 76 foreign currency dealers: Inside Canada's money service business 'clusters'
An IJF and CTV News investigation has found dozens of cases across Canada where multiple money services businesses (MSBs) are incorporated at the same address, sometimes without the knowledge or consent of the location's actual occupant. One money laundering expert calls it an 'abuse of the system.'
U.K. police officer suspended after video appears to show a man being kicked in head
A British police officer was suspended from all duties Thursday after a video was posted on social media that appeared to show an officer kicking and stamping on the head of a man lying on the floor of a terminal at Manchester Airport.
'I'm so broke': Two Toronto women speak out after losing $76,000 in romance scam
Two women from the Toronto area are speaking out after losing thousands of dollars to a romance scam, including a single mother who lost $62,000.
Barrie-Innisfil MPP 'blacked-out' and crashed car into window of child care centre
Staff at a Barrie child care centre say they are frustrated by what they call a local MPP's inadequate response after a car crashed through a window in one of the toddler rooms.
Norad intercepts Russian and Chinese bombers operating together near Alaska in apparent first
The North American Aerospace Defence Command (Norad) intercepted two Russian and two Chinese bombers flying near Alaska Wednesday in what appears to be the first time the two countries have been intercepted while operating together.
Biden explains why he ended re-election bid in Oval Office address
U.S. President Joe Biden on Wednesday delivered a solemn call to voters to defend the country's democracy as he laid out in an Oval Office address his decision to drop his bid for reelection and throw his support behind Vice President Kamala Harris.
Jasper mayor says alert system to be reviewed after message 'glitch'
More than 25,000 people have been displaced from Jasper National Park since wildfires started to threaten the picturesque corner of Alberta Rockies on Monday, but the mayor of its namesake municipality says not everyone received an evacuation alert when it was sent out.